Ameworwor Ethel Rhodaline, Amu Hubert, Dowou Robert Kokou, Kye-Duodu Gideon, Amu Selasi, Bain Luchuo Engelbert
Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Fred Newton Binka School of Public Health, University of Health and Allied Science, Hohoe, Ghana.
Department of Population and Behavioural Sciences, Fred Newton Binka School of Public Health, University of Health and Allied Science, Hohoe, Ghana.
Arch Public Health. 2024 Mar 14;82(1):36. doi: 10.1186/s13690-024-01263-y.
Globally, the burden of chronic non-communicable diseases is increasing rapidly and approximately one in three of all adults suffer from multiple chronic conditions. Therapeutic communication plays a crucial role in achieving curative, preventive, and promotive goals regarding chronic disease management. We examined therapeutic communication between health professionals and patients with chronic non-communicable diseases at the Ho Teaching Hospital.
We adopted a concurrent mixed-methods approach. The quantitative aspect of the study was descriptive while the qualitative was explanatory. The quantitative study was conducted among 250 patients. The qualitative data was collected among eight health professionals. A stratified sampling and simple random sampling methods were used to recruit patients for the quantitative survey while purposive and convenient sampling was used for the qualitative aspect of the study. The quantitative data was collected using a semi-structured questionnaire while the qualitative data was collected using an in-depth interview guide. The quantitative data were analyzed using STATA v17 and the qualitative data were analyzed thematically using Atlas ti. The major themes that emerged were, therapeutic communication practices, barriers to therapeutic communication and possible solutions to good therapeutic communication.
We found that 37% patients were 60 years and above with 53.2% being females. It was noted that 36.4% of patients have had tertiary-level education. We found that 59.2% of patients reported having good therapeutic communication with health professionals. We, however, noted that male participants were 92% less likely to practice good therapeutic communication compared with females (aOR = 0.92,95% Cl = 0.46-1.84). Health professionals' activities to ensure good therapeutic practices included their capacity to listen, build rapport with their patients, and clarify information. We found that the major facilitators of good therapeutic communication included trust in the health professionals (90.4%), conducive environment (93.2%), using simple and plain language by health professionals (92.0%) We found that there are myriad of barriers that impede communication process. This included language, health professionals' inability to break terminologies, and the unconscious state of patients.
The study revealed that there was good therapeutic communication between health professionals and patients with CNCDs. Nevertheless, it was also identified that ineffective therapeutic communication between health professionals and their patients due to barriers like language could lead to dissatisfaction with care, misdiagnosis, and noncompliance to treatment regimen. For Ghana as a country to achieve SDG target 3.4 by reducing mortality due to NCDs and improve wellbeing of patients by 2030, it will be imperative on Ghana Health Service to design communication strategy training for health professionals that could help improve therapeutic communication between patients and health professionals.
在全球范围内,慢性非传染性疾病的负担正在迅速增加,大约三分之一的成年人患有多种慢性病。治疗性沟通在实现慢性病管理的治愈、预防和促进目标方面起着至关重要的作用。我们在霍教学医院研究了卫生专业人员与慢性非传染性疾病患者之间的治疗性沟通。
我们采用了同步混合方法。该研究的定量部分是描述性的,而定性部分是解释性的。定量研究在250名患者中进行。定性数据是从8名卫生专业人员那里收集的。定量调查采用分层抽样和简单随机抽样方法招募患者,而定性研究采用目的抽样和方便抽样。定量数据通过半结构化问卷收集,而定性数据通过深入访谈指南收集。定量数据使用STATA v17进行分析,定性数据使用Atlas ti进行主题分析。出现的主要主题包括治疗性沟通实践、治疗性沟通的障碍以及良好治疗性沟通的可能解决方案。
我们发现37%的患者年龄在60岁及以上,其中53.2%为女性。值得注意的是,36.4%的患者接受过高等教育。我们发现59.2%的患者报告与卫生专业人员有良好的治疗性沟通。然而,我们注意到,与女性相比,男性参与者进行良好治疗性沟通的可能性低92%(调整后比值比=0.92,95%置信区间=0.46-1.84)。卫生专业人员确保良好治疗实践的活动包括他们倾听、与患者建立融洽关系以及澄清信息的能力。我们发现良好治疗性沟通的主要促进因素包括对卫生专业人员的信任(90.4%)、有利的环境(93.2%)、卫生专业人员使用简单易懂的语言(92.0%)。我们发现有无数障碍阻碍沟通进程。这包括语言、卫生专业人员无法解释术语以及患者的无意识状态。
该研究表明,卫生专业人员与慢性非传染性疾病患者之间存在良好的治疗性沟通。然而,也发现由于语言等障碍,卫生专业人员与患者之间无效的治疗性沟通可能导致对护理的不满、误诊和不遵守治疗方案。为了使加纳作为一个国家到2030年通过降低非传染性疾病导致的死亡率实现可持续发展目标3.4并改善患者的健康状况,加纳卫生服务部门必须为卫生专业人员设计沟通策略培训,这有助于改善患者与卫生专业人员之间的治疗性沟通。