Yang Hye Jin, Yang Ji-Hye, Jung Si Cheol, Choi Chulhwan, Bum Chul-Ho
Department of Physical Education, Graduate School, Kyung Hee University, Yongin-si, Gyeonggi-do, Republic of Korea.
Department of Physical Education, Gachon University, Seongnam-si, Gyeonggi-do, Republic of Korea.
Front Psychol. 2024 Mar 12;15:1361470. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1361470. eCollection 2024.
This study investigated the differences in amateur golfers' perceptions of instructor expertise, instructor credibility, and lesson participation intention depending on the golf instructor's certification level to investigate whether placebo and nocebo effects exist depending on the certification level. Accordingly, the study analyzed 153 amateur golfers with at least 1 year of playing experience, and the results were as follows: First, there was a difference in the perception of instructor expertise among amateur golfers depending on the golf instructor's certification level. Specifically, there were significant differences in perceived performance and teaching skills but no differences in personality and emphasis on basic principles. Second, the participants reported significant differences in their perceptions of instructor credibility depending on the instructor's certification level. Instructor credibility of the tournament professional group was the highest, whereas that of the amateur group was the lowest. Third, the results showed differences in lesson participation intention among amateur golfers depending on the instructor's certification level. Lesson participation intention was higher for semi-professional and tournament professional instructors than for amateur instructors. These results verified the presence of psychological biases, such as placebo/nocebo effects, that result in differences in the perception of instructor expertise, instructor credibility, and lesson participation intention depending on the certification level of instructors. Additionally, based on the data obtained from this study, further research is required to improve the performance of golf instructors and create an efficient teaching environment.
本研究调查了业余高尔夫球手对教练专业水平、教练可信度以及课程参与意愿的认知差异,具体取决于高尔夫教练的认证级别,以探究是否存在因认证级别而异的安慰剂和反安慰剂效应。据此,该研究分析了153名有至少1年打球经验的业余高尔夫球手,结果如下:第一,业余高尔夫球手对教练专业水平的认知因高尔夫教练的认证级别而异。具体而言,在感知表现和教学技能方面存在显著差异,但在个性和对基本原则的强调方面没有差异。第二,参与者报告称,他们对教练可信度的认知因教练的认证级别而异。锦标赛职业组的教练可信度最高,而业余组的教练可信度最低。第三,结果显示,业余高尔夫球手的课程参与意愿因教练的认证级别而异。半职业和锦标赛职业教练的课程参与意愿高于业余教练。这些结果证实了心理偏差的存在,如安慰剂/反安慰剂效应,这导致了根据教练认证级别在教练专业水平认知、教练可信度认知和课程参与意愿方面的差异。此外,基于本研究获得的数据,需要进一步研究以提高高尔夫教练的表现并创造高效的教学环境。