Buck Philip O, Gomes Dumingu Aparna, Beck Ekkehard, Kirson Noam, Mattera Matthew, Carroll Stuart, Ultsch Bernhard, Jayasundara Kavisha, Uhart Mathieu, Garrison Louis P
Moderna Inc., Cambridge, MA 02139, USA.
Analysis Group, Inc., Menlo Park, CA 94025, USA.
Vaccines (Basel). 2024 Feb 24;12(3):234. doi: 10.3390/vaccines12030234.
The COVID-19 pandemic's dramatic impact has been a vivid reminder that vaccines-especially in the context of infectious respiratory viruses-provide enormous societal value, well beyond the healthcare system perspective which anchors most Health Technology Assessment (HTA) and National Immunization Technical Advisory Group (NITAG) evaluation frameworks. Furthermore, the development of modified ribonucleic acid-based (mRNA-based) and nanoparticle vaccine technologies has brought into focus several new value drivers previously absent from the discourse on vaccines as public health interventions such as increased vaccine adaptation capabilities, the improved ability to develop combination vaccines, and more efficient vaccine manufacturing and production processes. We review these novel value dimensions and discuss how they might be measured and incorporated within existing value frameworks using existing methods. To realize the full potential of next-generation vaccine platforms and ensure their widespread availability across populations and health systems, it is important that value frameworks utilized by HTAs and NITAGs properly reflect the full range of benefits for population health and well-being and cost efficiencies that these new vaccines platforms provide.
新冠疫情的巨大影响生动地提醒人们,疫苗——尤其是在传染性呼吸道病毒的背景下——具有巨大的社会价值,这远远超出了以医疗保健系统为视角的范畴,而大多数卫生技术评估(HTA)和国家免疫技术咨询小组(NITAG)的评估框架都以该系统为基础。此外,基于修饰核糖核酸(mRNA)和纳米颗粒的疫苗技术的发展,使人们关注到一些此前在疫苗作为公共卫生干预措施的讨论中未曾出现的新价值驱动因素,例如疫苗适应能力增强、研发联合疫苗的能力提高以及疫苗制造和生产流程更高效。我们回顾这些新的价值维度,并讨论如何使用现有方法对其进行衡量并纳入现有价值框架。为了充分发挥下一代疫苗平台的潜力,并确保其在人群和卫生系统中广泛可得,重要的是,HTA和NITAG所使用的价值框架应恰当地反映这些新疫苗平台为人群健康和福祉带来的全部益处以及成本效益。