Rémillard-Labrosse Gaudeline, Cohen Sydney, Boucher Éliane, Gagnon Kéryanne, Vasilev Filip, Mihajlović Aleksandar I, FitzHarris Greg
Centre de Recherche du Centre Hospitalier de I'Université de Montréal (CRCHUM), Montréal, QC, Canada.
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Université de Montréal, Montréal, QC, Canada.
Front Cell Dev Biol. 2024 Mar 8;12:1337937. doi: 10.3389/fcell.2024.1337937. eCollection 2024.
Culture of oocytes and embryos in media under oil is a cornerstone of fertility treatment, and extensively employed in experimental investigation of early mammalian development. It has been noted anecdotally by some that certain small molecule inhibitors might lose activity in oil-covered culture systems, presumably by drug partitioning into the oil. Here we took a pseudo-pharmacological approach to appraise this formally using mouse oocytes and embryos. Using different culture dish designs with defined media:oil volume ratios, we show that the EC of the widely employed microtubule poison nocodazole shifts as a function of the media:oil ratio, such that nocodazole concentrations that prevent cell division in oil-free culture fail to in oil-covered media drops. Relatively subtle changes in culture dish design lead to measurable changes in EC. This effect is not specific to one type of culture oil, and can be readily observed both in oocyte and embryo culture experiments. We subsequently applied a similar approach to a small panel of widely employed cell cycle-related inhibitors, finding that most lose activity in standard oil-covered oocyte/embryo culture systems. Our data suggest that loss of small molecule activity in oil-covered oocyte and embryo culture is a widespread phenomenon with potentially far-reaching implications for data reproducibility, and we recommend avoiding oil-covered culture for experiments employing inhibitors/drugs wherever possible.
在油下培养基中培养卵母细胞和胚胎是辅助生殖治疗的基石,并广泛应用于早期哺乳动物发育的实验研究。一些人曾 anecdotal 地指出,某些小分子抑制剂可能在油覆盖的培养系统中失去活性,推测是因为药物分配到油中。在这里,我们采用了一种伪药理学方法,使用小鼠卵母细胞和胚胎对此进行正式评估。通过使用具有确定培养基:油体积比的不同培养皿设计,我们表明广泛使用的微管毒物诺考达唑的 EC 随着培养基:油比的变化而变化,以至于在无油培养中阻止细胞分裂的诺考达唑浓度在油覆盖的培养基中无法降低。培养皿设计中相对细微的变化会导致 EC 发生可测量的变化。这种效应并非特定于某一种培养油,并且在卵母细胞和胚胎培养实验中都能很容易地观察到。我们随后对一小部分广泛使用的细胞周期相关抑制剂采用了类似的方法,发现大多数在标准的油覆盖卵母细胞/胚胎培养系统中失去活性。我们的数据表明,油覆盖的卵母细胞和胚胎培养中小分子活性的丧失是一种普遍现象,对数据的可重复性可能具有深远影响,并且我们建议在可能的情况下,对于使用抑制剂/药物的实验避免采用油覆盖培养。