Lopes Sílvia, Bruno de Sousa Andrea, Delalibera Mayra, Namukwaya Elizabeth, Cohen Joachim, Gomes Barbara
Faculty of Medicine, University of Coimbra, Coimbra, Portugal.
NOVA National School of Public Health, Public Health Research Centre, Comprehensive Health Research Center, CHRC, NOVA University Lisbon, Lisbon, Portugal.
EClinicalMedicine. 2024 Jan 2;68:102399. doi: 10.1016/j.eclinm.2023.102399. eCollection 2024 Feb.
During the coronavirus 2019 disease (COVID-19) pandemic, health systems had to respond to the needs of COVID-19 patients, while caring for patients with other life-threatening conditions. Pandemics, such as the COVID-19 pandemic, stir global health and mortality patterns. This is likely to include trends in dying places. In this paper, we examine trends in place of death for adults in 32 countries, comparing the initial COVID-19 pandemic years (2020-2021) with the eight years before the pandemic (2012-2019).
Data on place of death for all adults (18 years and over) that died from 1 January 2012 to 31 December 2021 were requested (47 countries approached, 32 included). The classification of place of death varied widely between countries. "Home" was the most common category, the remaining category groups comprised "hospital or health institution", "other defined", and "ill-defined". We analysed place of death data in an aggregate form, by sex, age group, and selected underlying causes of death (cancer, dementia, and COVID-19).
The study included 100.7 million people (51.5% male, 68.0% with ≥70 years), 20.4% died from cancer and 5.8% from dementia; 30.8% of deaths took place at home. The percentage of home deaths rose from 30.1% in 2012-2013 to 30.9% in 2018-2019 and further to 32.2% in the pandemic (2020-2021). Home deaths increased during the pandemic in 23 countries. In most countries the rise was greater in women and cancer; age differences were not consistent.
Our study shows that there was a rise in home deaths during the pandemic, but with variability across countries, sex, age, and causes of death. The sex difference observed in most countries may have several explanations, including more engagement of women in discussions about end of life care planning and hospital admission avoidance. A higher rise of home deaths among people dying of cancer may be explained by the more predictable disease trajectory compared to non-malignant conditions, as well as earlier and better integrated palliative care.
This work is part of the EOLinPLACE Project, which has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union's Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (grant agreement No 948609).
在2019冠状病毒病(COVID-19)大流行期间,卫生系统必须在照顾患有其他危及生命疾病患者的同时,应对COVID-19患者的需求。诸如COVID-19大流行之类的疫情会扰乱全球卫生和死亡率模式。这可能包括死亡地点的趋势。在本文中,我们研究了32个国家成年人的死亡地点趋势,将COVID-19大流行初期(2020 - 2021年)与大流行前的八年(2012 - 2019年)进行比较。
我们索取了2012年1月1日至2021年12月31日期间所有死亡成年人(18岁及以上)的死亡地点数据(联系了47个国家,纳入了32个国家)。各国死亡地点的分类差异很大。“家中”是最常见的类别,其余类别组包括“医院或医疗机构”、“其他明确地点”和“不明确地点”。我们按性别、年龄组以及选定的潜在死因(癌症、痴呆症和COVID-19)以汇总形式分析了死亡地点数据。
该研究纳入了1.007亿人(男性占51.5%,70岁及以上者占68.0%),20.4%的人死于癌症,5.8%死于痴呆症;30.8%的死亡发生在家中。家中死亡的比例从2012 - 2013年的30.1%上升至2018 - 2019年的30.9%,在大流行期间(2020 - 2021年)进一步升至32.2%。23个国家在大流行期间家中死亡人数增加。在大多数国家,女性和癌症患者家中死亡人数的上升幅度更大;年龄差异并不一致。
我们的研究表明,大流行期间家中死亡人数有所上升,但在不同国家、性别、年龄和死因之间存在差异。在大多数国家观察到的性别差异可能有多种解释,包括女性更多地参与临终护理规划讨论以及避免住院。与非恶性疾病相比,癌症患者家中死亡人数上升幅度更高,这可能是由于疾病轨迹更可预测,以及更早且更完善地整合了姑息治疗。
这项工作是EOLinPLACE项目的一部分,该项目已获得欧盟“地平线2020”研究与创新计划下欧洲研究理事会(ERC)的资助(资助协议编号948609)。