DiFranza Lanny T, Daniel Emily, Serban Geo, Thomas Steven M, Santoriello Dominick, Ratner Lloyd E, D'Agati Vivette D, Vasilescu Elena-Rodica, Husain Syed Ali, Batal Ibrahim
Pathology and Cell Biology, Columbia University Irving Medical Center, New York, NY, United States.
Medicine, Nephrology, Columbia University Irving Medical Center, New York, NY, United States.
Front Med (Lausanne). 2024 Mar 14;11:1369225. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2024.1369225. eCollection 2024.
Although a few registry-based studies have shown associations between receiving kidney allografts from Black donors and shorter allograft survival, detailed, large, single-center studies accounting for common confounding factors are lacking. Furthermore, pathologic alterations underlying this potential disparity have not been systematically studied. We performed a retrospective clinical-pathological study of kidney transplant recipients who received kidney allografts from either Black ( = 407) or White ( = 1,494) donors at Columbia University Irving Medical Center from 2005 to 2018, with median follow-up of 4.5 years post-transplantation. Black donor race was independently associated with allograft failure (adjusted HR = 1.34, 0.02) and recipients of kidney allografts from Black donors had a higher incidence of collapsing glomerulopathy [7.4% vs. 1.9%, OR = 4.17, 0.001]. When causes of allograft failure were examined, only allograft failure following development of collapsing glomerulopathy was more frequent in recipients of allografts from Black donors [15% vs. 5%, OR = 3.16, = 0.004]. Notably, when patients who developed collapsing glomerulopathy were excluded from analysis, receiving kidney allografts from Black donors was not independently associated with allograft failure (adjusted HR = 1.24, = 0.10). These findings revealed that, compared with recipients of kidney allografts from White donors, recipients of kidneys from Black donors have modestly shorter allograft survival and a higher probability of developing collapsing glomerulopathy, which negatively impacts allograft outcome. Identification of collapsing glomerulopathy risk factors may help decrease this complication and improve allograft survival, which optimally may reduce racial disparities post-transplantation.
尽管一些基于登记处的研究表明,接受黑人捐赠者的肾移植与移植肾存活时间较短之间存在关联,但缺乏考虑常见混杂因素的详细、大型单中心研究。此外,这种潜在差异背后的病理改变尚未得到系统研究。我们对2005年至2018年在哥伦比亚大学欧文医学中心接受黑人(n = 407)或白人(n = 1494)捐赠者肾移植的肾移植受者进行了一项回顾性临床病理研究,移植后中位随访时间为4.5年。黑人捐赠者种族与移植肾失败独立相关(校正风险比 = 1.34,P = 0.02),接受黑人捐赠者肾移植的受者发生塌陷性肾小球病的发生率更高[7.4%对1.9%,比值比 = 4.17,P = 0.001]。当检查移植肾失败的原因时,只有在发生塌陷性肾小球病后出现的移植肾失败在接受黑人捐赠者移植肾的受者中更为常见[15%对5%,比值比 = 3.16,P = 0.004]。值得注意的是,当将发生塌陷性肾小球病的患者排除在分析之外时,接受黑人捐赠者的肾移植与移植肾失败没有独立关联(校正风险比 = 1.24,P = 0.10)。这些发现表明,与接受白人捐赠者肾移植的受者相比,接受黑人捐赠者肾移植的受者移植肾存活时间略短,发生塌陷性肾小球病的可能性更高,这对移植肾结局产生负面影响。确定塌陷性肾小球病的危险因素可能有助于减少这种并发症并提高移植肾存活率,这可能最佳地减少移植后的种族差异。