Poppe Ronald, van der Zee Sophie, Taylor Paul J, Anderson Ross J, Veltkamp Remco C
Information and Computing Sciences, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Applied Economics, Erasmus School of Economics, Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
J Nonverbal Behav. 2024;48(1):137-159. doi: 10.1007/s10919-023-00450-9. Epub 2024 Jan 16.
A significant body of research has investigated potential correlates of deception and bodily behavior. The vast majority of these studies consider discrete, subjectively coded bodily movements such as specific hand or head gestures. Such studies fail to consider quantitative aspects of body movement such as the precise movement direction, magnitude and timing. In this paper, we employ an innovative data mining approach to systematically study bodily correlates of deception. We re-analyze motion capture data from a previously published deception study, and experiment with different data coding options. We report how deception detection rates are affected by variables such as body part, the coding of the pose and movement, the length of the observation, and the amount of measurement noise. Our results demonstrate the feasibility of a data mining approach, with detection rates above 65%, significantly outperforming human judgement (52.80%). Owing to the systematic analysis, our analyses allow for an understanding of the importance of various coding factor. Moreover, we can reconcile seemingly discrepant findings in previous research. Our approach highlights the merits of data-driven research to support the validation and development of deception theory.
大量研究调查了欺骗行为与身体行为之间的潜在关联。这些研究绝大多数关注离散的、主观编码的身体动作,比如特定的手部或头部姿势。此类研究未能考虑身体动作的量化方面,如精确的动作方向、幅度和时间。在本文中,我们采用一种创新的数据挖掘方法来系统地研究欺骗行为的身体关联。我们重新分析了之前发表的一项欺骗研究中的动作捕捉数据,并对不同的数据编码选项进行了实验。我们报告了欺骗检测率是如何受到诸如身体部位、姿势和动作的编码、观察时长以及测量噪声量等变量影响的。我们的结果证明了数据挖掘方法的可行性,检测率超过65%,显著优于人类判断(52.80%)。由于进行了系统分析,我们的分析有助于理解各种编码因素的重要性。此外,我们能够调和先前研究中看似矛盾的发现。我们的方法凸显了数据驱动研究对于支持欺骗理论的验证和发展的优点。