Eichenberg Christiane, Schneider Raphaela, Auvera Phillip, Aranyi Gabor, Huber Kurt
Faculty of Medicine, Institute of Psychosomatics, Sigmund Freud Private University, Vienna, Austria.
Sigmund Freud Private University, Medical Faculty, Vienna, Austria.
Front Psychiatry. 2024 Mar 22;15:1334552. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2024.1334552. eCollection 2024.
The COVID-19 pandemic placed an extraordinary burden on health care workers (HCW), who are reported to suffer from great mental stress. The current study investigates the mental health of HCW in the later phases of the pandemic.
HCW completed the following questionnaires online (06/2021-02/2022, =159): demographics (age, gender, profession, ward), Impact of Event Scale (IES-R, posttraumatic stress), State Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI-S, state anxiety), stress-coping questionnaire (SVF-78), and bespoke corona-specific stress and protective-factor questions (5 items each). We used factor analysis to test scale properties and regression-type methods (t-tests, ANOVA, multiple regression) for hypothesis tests and effect-size estimation.
RESULTS/DISCUSSION: Mental stress in HCW is influenced by similar factors as described for earlier phases. However, differences to earlier phases were found in ward affiliation which is no longer a variable of concern for explaining differences in mental health of HCW. Further, even if nurses are the occupational group with the highest mental stress as in prior research, detailed analysis shows that medical specialists with close proximity to patients with a high-level of responsibility are the most burdened sub-group. Unlike nurses, they suffer from high levels of anxiety in addition to high levels of post-traumatic and COVID-specific stress. Analyses showed further that COVID-specific stress is the strongest predictor of mental stress, wherein COVID-specific stress factors remain the same as reported in literature on the early pandemic phases. HCW showed to use still more positive than negative coping strategies. Negative strategies increased as expected mental stress, whereas positive strategies alleviated only anxiety. Additionally, we found that doctors benefited from many protective factors while nurses had access to fewer protective factors like earlier waves.
Data show that HCW still suffer from mental stress in the third year of the pandemic. HCW of all hospital wards may be affected by mental stress and need attention and protective measures. Medical specialists are the most burdened subgroup. Detailed analyses show that properties other than occupation, gender, or ward affiliation are more appropriate to evaluate mental stress of HCW. The findings have implications for developing specialized protection strategies for the post-pandemic phase and future pandemics.
新冠疫情给医护人员带来了巨大负担,据报道他们承受着巨大的精神压力。本研究调查了疫情后期医护人员的心理健康状况。
医护人员于2021年6月至2022年2月在线完成了以下问卷(n = 159):人口统计学信息(年龄、性别、职业、病房)、事件影响量表(IES-R,创伤后应激)、状态特质焦虑量表(STAI-S,状态焦虑)、压力应对问卷(SVF-78)以及定制的新冠疫情特定压力和保护因素问题(各5项)。我们使用因子分析来检验量表特性,并使用回归类型方法(t检验、方差分析、多元回归)进行假设检验和效应量估计。
结果/讨论:医护人员的精神压力受与早期阶段类似的因素影响。然而,在病房归属方面发现了与早期阶段的差异,病房归属不再是解释医护人员心理健康差异的一个值得关注的变量。此外,尽管如先前研究一样护士是精神压力最高的职业群体,但详细分析表明,与高责任水平患者密切接触的医学专家是负担最重的亚组。与护士不同,他们除了有高水平的创伤后应激和新冠疫情特定压力外,还承受着高水平的焦虑。分析进一步表明,新冠疫情特定压力是精神压力的最强预测因素,其中新冠疫情特定压力因素与早期疫情阶段文献报道的相同。医护人员仍然更多地使用积极而非消极的应对策略。消极策略如预期的那样增加了精神压力,而积极策略仅减轻了焦虑。此外,我们发现医生受益于许多保护因素,而护士获得的保护因素比早期疫情波次时更少。
数据表明,在疫情的第三年医护人员仍然承受着精神压力。所有医院病房的医护人员都可能受到精神压力的影响,需要关注和保护措施。医学专家是负担最重的亚组。详细分析表明,职业、性别或病房归属以外的因素更适合评估医护人员的精神压力。这些发现对制定疫情后阶段及未来疫情的专门保护策略具有启示意义。