Luiz L M D, Marques I A, Folador J P, Andrade A O
Centre for Innovation and Technology Assessment in Health, Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Federal University of Uberlândia, Uberlândia, Brazil.
Centre for Innovation and Technology Assessment in Health, Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Federal University of Uberlândia, Uberlândia, Brazil.
Neurologia (Engl Ed). 2024 May;39(4):345-352. doi: 10.1016/j.nrleng.2021.08.006.
Reliable assessment of individuals with Parkinson's disease (PD) is essential for providing adequate treatment. Clinical assessment is a complex and time-consuming task, especially for bradykinesia, since its evaluation can be influenced by the degree of experience of the examiner, patient collaboration and individual bias. Improvement of the clinical evaluation can be obtained by considering assessments from several professionals. However, this is only true when inter and intra-rater agreement are high. Recently, the Movement Disorder Society highlighted, during the COVID-19 pandemic, the need to develop and validate technologies for remote assessment of the motor status of people with PD. Thus, this study introduces an objective strategy for the remote evaluation of bradykinesia using multi-specialist analysis.
Twelve volunteers with PD participated and these were asked to execute finger tapping, hand opening/closing and pronation/supination movements. Each task was recorded and rated by fourteen PD health experts for each patient. The scores were assessed on an individual basis. Intra and inter-rater agreement and correlation were estimated.
The results showed that agreements and correlations between experienced examiners were high with low variability. In addition, group analysis was noted as possessing the potential to solve individual inconsistency bias.
Furthermore, this study demonstrated the need for a group with prior training and experience, along with indicating the importance for the development of a clinical protocol that can use telemedicine for the evaluation of individuals with PD, as well as the inclusion of a specialized mediating group. In Addition, this research helps to the development of a valid remote assessment of bradykinesia.
对帕金森病(PD)患者进行可靠评估对于提供充分治疗至关重要。临床评估是一项复杂且耗时的任务,尤其是对于运动迟缓而言,因为其评估可能会受到检查者经验程度、患者配合度以及个体偏差的影响。通过考虑多位专业人员的评估可以改善临床评估。然而,只有当评估者之间和评估者内部的一致性较高时才会如此。最近,运动障碍协会在新冠疫情期间强调,需要开发和验证用于远程评估帕金森病患者运动状态的技术。因此,本研究引入了一种使用多专家分析进行运动迟缓远程评估的客观策略。
12名帕金森病志愿者参与其中,他们被要求执行手指敲击、手的张开/闭合以及旋前/旋后运动。每项任务都被记录下来,并由14名帕金森病健康专家对每位患者进行评分。分数是基于个体进行评估的。评估者内部和评估者之间的一致性及相关性进行了估计。
结果表明,经验丰富的检查者之间的一致性和相关性较高,变异性较低。此外,分组分析被认为具有解决个体不一致偏差的潜力。
此外,本研究表明需要一个经过预先培训且有经验的小组,同时指出了制定临床方案的重要性,该方案可利用远程医疗评估帕金森病患者,以及纳入一个专业的调解小组。此外,这项研究有助于开发有效的运动迟缓远程评估方法。