Ben-Zeev Dror, Larsen Anna, Attah Dzifa A, Obeng Kwadwo, Beaulieu Alexa, Asafo Seth M, Gavi Jonathan Kuma, Kadakia Arya, Sottie Emmanuel Quame, Ohene Sammy, Kola Lola, Hallgren Kevin, Snyder Jaime, Collins Pamela Y, Ofori-Atta Angela
Behavioral Research in Technology and Engineering Center, Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, United States.
Department of Epidemiology, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, United States.
JMIR Ment Health. 2024 Mar 27;11:e53096. doi: 10.2196/53096.
In West Africa, healers greatly outnumber trained mental health professionals. People with serious mental illness (SMI) are often seen by healers in "prayer camps" where they may also experience human rights abuses. We developed "M&M," an 8-week-long dual-pronged intervention involving (1) a smartphone-delivered toolkit designed to expose healers to brief psychosocial interventions and encourage them to preserve human rights (M-Healer app), and (2) a visiting nurse who provides medications to their patients (Mobile Nurse).
We examined the feasibility, acceptability, safety, and preliminary effectiveness of the M&M intervention in real-world prayer camp settings.
We conducted a single-arm field trial of M&M with people with SMI and healers at a prayer camp in Ghana. Healers were provided smartphones with M-Healer installed and were trained by practice facilitators to use the digital toolkit. In parallel, a study nurse visited their prayer camp to administer medications to their patients. Clinical assessors administered study measures to participants with SMI at pretreatment (baseline), midtreatment (4 weeks) and post treatment (8 weeks).
Seventeen participants were enrolled and most (n=15, 88.3%) were retained. Participants had an average age of 44.3 (SD 13.9) years and 59% (n=10) of them were male. Fourteen (82%) participants had a diagnosis of schizophrenia and 2 (18%) were diagnosed with bipolar disorder. Four healers were trained to use M-Healer. On average, they self-initiated app use 31.9 (SD 28.9) times per week. Healers watched an average of 19.1 (SD 21.2) videos, responded to 1.5 (SD 2.4) prompts, and used the app for 5.3 (SD 2.7) days weekly. Pre-post analyses revealed a significant and clinically meaningful reduction in psychiatric symptom severity (Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale score range 52.3 to 30.9; Brief Symptom Inventory score range 76.4 to 27.9), psychological distress (Talbieh Brief Distress Inventory score range 37.7 to 16.9), shame (Other as Shamer Scale score range 41.9 to 28.5), and stigma (Brief Internalized Stigma of Mental Illness Scale score range 11.8 to 10.3). We recorded a significant reduction in days chained (1.6 to 0.5) and a promising trend for reduction in the days of forced fasting (2.6 to 0.0, P=.06). We did not identify significant pre-post changes in patient-reported working alliance with healers (Working Alliance Inventory), depressive symptom severity (Patient Health Questionnaire-9), quality of life (Lehman Quality of Life Interview for the Mentally Ill), beliefs about medication (Beliefs about Medications Questionnaire-General Harm subscale), or other human rights abuses. No major side effects, health and safety violations, or serious adverse events occurred over the course of the trial.
The M&M intervention proved to be feasible, acceptable, safe, and clinically promising. Preliminary findings suggest that the M-Healer toolkit may have shifted healers' behaviors at the prayer camp so that they commit fewer human rights abuses.
在西非,治疗师的数量远远超过训练有素的心理健康专业人员。患有严重精神疾病(SMI)的人常常在“祈祷营”中接受治疗师的诊治,在那里他们可能还会遭受人权侵犯。我们开发了“M&M”,这是一项为期8周的双管齐下的干预措施,包括:(1)一个通过智能手机提供的工具包,旨在让治疗师接触简短的心理社会干预措施,并鼓励他们维护人权(M-治疗师应用程序);(2)一名访视护士,为他们的患者提供药物(移动护士)。
我们研究了M&M干预措施在现实世界的祈祷营环境中的可行性、可接受性、安全性和初步有效性。
我们在加纳的一个祈祷营对患有SMI的人和治疗师进行了M&M的单臂现场试验。为治疗师提供安装了M-治疗师应用程序的智能手机,并由实践促进者培训他们使用这个数字工具包。同时,一名研究护士前往他们的祈祷营为患者给药。临床评估人员在治疗前(基线)、治疗中期(4周)和治疗后(8周)对患有SMI的参与者进行研究测量。
招募了17名参与者,大多数(n = 15,88.3%)被保留下来。参与者的平均年龄为44.3(标准差13.9)岁,其中59%(n = 10)为男性。14名(82%)参与者被诊断为精神分裂症,2名(18%)被诊断为双相情感障碍。4名治疗师接受了使用M-治疗师应用程序的培训。平均而言,他们每周自行使用应用程序31.9(标准差28.9)次。治疗师平均观看了19.1(标准差21.2)个视频,回复了1.5(标准差2.4)个提示,并且每周使用该应用程序5.3(标准差2.7)天。治疗前后分析显示,精神症状严重程度(简明精神病评定量表评分范围从52.3降至30.9;简明症状量表评分范围从76.4降至27.9)、心理困扰(塔尔比耶简明困扰量表评分范围从37.7降至16.9)、羞耻感(他人作为羞耻者量表评分范围从41.9降至28.5)和耻辱感(精神疾病简明内化耻辱感量表评分范围从11.8降至10.3)有显著且具有临床意义的降低。我们记录到被锁链束缚的天数显著减少(从1.6天降至0.5天),并且在强制禁食天数的减少方面有一个有希望的趋势(从2.6天降至0.0天,P = 0.06)。我们没有发现患者报告的与治疗师的工作联盟(工作联盟量表)、抑郁症状严重程度(患者健康问卷-9)、生活质量(针对精神病患者的雷曼生活质量访谈)、对药物的信念(药物信念问卷-一般危害子量表)或其他侵犯人权行为在治疗前后有显著变化。在试验过程中没有发生重大副作用、健康和安全违规行为或严重不良事件。
M&M干预措施被证明是可行的、可接受的、安全的,并且在临床上有前景。初步研究结果表明,M-治疗师工具包可能改变了祈祷营中治疗师的行为,从而减少了他们侵犯人权的行为。