University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham, Alabama, USA.
Patient Advocate Foundation, Hampton, Virginia, USA.
Cancer Med. 2024 Apr;13(8):e7185. doi: 10.1002/cam4.7185.
Though financial hardship is a well-documented adverse effect of standard-of-care cancer treatment, little is known about out-of-pocket costs and their impact on patients participating in cancer clinical trials. This study explored the financial effects of cancer clinical trial participation.
This cross-sectional analysis used survey data collected in December 2022 and May 2023 from individuals with cancer previously served by Patient Advocate Foundation, a nonprofit organization providing social needs navigation and financial assistance to US adults with a chronic illness. Surveys included questions on cancer clinical trial participation, trial-related financial hardship, and sociodemographic data. Descriptive and bivariate analyses were conducted using Cramer's V to estimate the in-sample magnitude of association. Associations between trial-related financial hardship and sociodemographics were estimated using adjusted relative risks (aRR) and corresponding 95% confidence intervals (CI) from modified Poisson regression models with robust standard errors.
Of 650 survey respondents, 18% (N = 118) reported ever participating in a cancer clinical trial. Of those, 47% (n = 55) reported financial hardship as a result of their trial participation. Respondents reporting trial-related financial hardship were more often unemployed or disabled (58% vs. 43%; V = 0.15), Medicare enrolled (53% vs. 40%; V = 0.15), and traveled >1 h to their cancer provider (45% vs. 17%; V = 0.33) compared to respondents reporting no hardship. Respondents who experienced trial-related financial hardship most often reported expenses from travel (reported by 71% of respondents), medical bills (58%), dining out (40%), or housing needs (40%). Modeling results indicated that respondents traveling >1 h vs. ≤30 min to their cancer provider had a 2.2× higher risk of financial hardship, even after adjusting for respondent race, income, employment, and insurance status (aRR = 2.2, 95% CI 1.3-3.8). Most respondents (53%) reported needing $200-$1000 per month to compensate for trial-related expenses. Over half (51%) of respondents reported less willingness to participate in future clinical trials due to incurred financial hardship. Notably, of patients who did not participate in a cancer clinical trial (n = 532), 13% declined participation due to cost.
Cancer clinical trial-related financial hardship, most often stemming from travel expenses, affected almost half of trial-enrolled patients. Interventions are needed to reduce adverse financial participation effects and potentially improve cancer clinical trial participation.
尽管经济困难是标准癌症治疗的一个有据可查的不良影响,但对于参与癌症临床试验患者的自付费用及其影响知之甚少。本研究探讨了癌症临床试验参与的财务影响。
本横断面分析使用 2022 年 12 月和 2023 年 5 月期间从患者倡导基金会(Patient Advocate Foundation)服务过的癌症患者收集的调查数据,该非盈利组织为美国患有慢性病的成年人提供社会需求导航和财务援助。调查包括有关癌症临床试验参与、与试验相关的经济困难以及社会人口统计学数据的问题。使用 Cramer 的 V 来估计样本内关联的幅度进行描述性和双变量分析。使用调整后的相对风险 (aRR) 和来自具有稳健标准差的修正泊松回归模型的相应 95%置信区间 (CI) 来估计与试验相关的经济困难与社会人口统计学之间的关联。
在 650 名调查受访者中,18%(N=118)报告曾参加过癌症临床试验。其中,47%(n=55)报告由于参与试验而遇到经济困难。报告与试验相关的经济困难的受访者更有可能失业或残疾(58%比 43%;V=0.15)、参加医疗保险(53%比 40%;V=0.15)和前往癌症提供者处超过 1 小时(45%比 17%;V=0.33)与报告无困难的受访者相比。报告与试验相关的经济困难的受访者最常报告旅行费用(71%的受访者报告)、医疗费用(58%)、外出就餐(40%)或住房需求(40%)。建模结果表明,与前往癌症提供者的时间≤30 分钟的受访者相比,前往癌症提供者的时间>1 小时的受访者财务困难的风险高 2.2 倍,即使在调整了受访者的种族、收入、就业和保险状况后也是如此(aRR=2.2,95%CI 1.3-3.8)。大多数受访者(53%)报告每月需要 200-1000 美元来补偿与试验相关的费用。超过一半(51%)的受访者表示,由于经济困难,他们不太愿意参加未来的临床试验。值得注意的是,在未参加癌症临床试验的患者中(n=532),有 13%的患者因费用问题而拒绝参与。
癌症临床试验相关的经济困难,主要源自旅行费用,影响了近一半的试验入组患者。需要采取干预措施来减轻不利的财务参与影响,并有可能提高癌症临床试验的参与率。