Department of Anesthesia, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Center, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Department of Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
BMC Cardiovasc Disord. 2024 Apr 20;24(1):215. doi: 10.1186/s12872-024-03862-7.
Research shows women experience higher mortality than men after cardiac surgery but information on sex-differences during postoperative recovery is limited. Days alive and out of hospital (DAH) combines death, readmission and length of stay, and may better quantify sex-differences during recovery. This main objective is to evaluate (i) how DAH at 30-days varies between sex and surgical procedure, (ii) DAH responsiveness to patient and surgical complexity, and (iii) longer-term prognostic value of DAH.
We evaluated 111,430 patients (26% female) who underwent one of three types of cardiac surgery (isolated coronary artery bypass [CABG], isolated non-CABG, combination procedures) between 2009 - 2019. Primary outcome was DAH at 30 days (DAH), secondary outcomes were DAH at 90 days (DAH) and 180 days (DAH). Data were stratified by sex and surgical group. Unadjusted and risk-adjusted analyses were conducted to determine the association of DAH with patient-, surgery-, and hospital-level characteristics. Patients were divided into two groups (below and above the 10th percentile) based on the number of days at DAH Proportion of patients below the 10th percentile at DAH that remained in this group at DAH and DAH were determined.
DAH were lower for women compared to men (22 vs. 23 days), and seen across all surgical groups (isolated CABG 23 vs. 24, isolated non-CABG 22 vs. 23, combined surgeries 19 vs. 21 days). Clinical risk factors including multimorbidity, socioeconomic status and surgical complexity were associated with lower DAH values, but women showed lower values of DAH compared to men for many factors. Among patients in the lowest 10th percentile at DAH, 80% of both females and males remained in the lowest 10th percentile at 90 days, while 72% of females and 76% males remained in that percentile at 180 days.
DAH is a responsive outcome to differences in patient and surgical risk factors. Further research is needed to identify new care pathways to reduce disparities in outcomes between male and female patients.
研究表明,女性在心脏手术后的死亡率高于男性,但术后恢复期的性别差异信息有限。存活且离院天数(DAH)综合了死亡、再入院和住院时间,可能更能量化恢复期的性别差异。本研究的主要目的是评估:(i)30 天 DAH 在性别和手术类型之间的差异;(ii)DAH 对患者和手术复杂性的反应性;以及(iii)DAH 的长期预后价值。
我们评估了 2009 年至 2019 年间接受三种类型心脏手术(单纯冠状动脉旁路移植术 [CABG]、非 CABG 单纯手术、联合手术)之一的 111430 例患者(26%为女性)。主要结局为 30 天 DAH(DAH),次要结局为 90 天 DAH(DAH)和 180 天 DAH(DAH)。根据性别和手术组对数据进行分层。进行了未经调整和风险调整的分析,以确定 DAH 与患者、手术和医院水平特征之间的关联。根据 DAH 的天数,患者被分为两组(低于和高于第 10 百分位数),并确定在 DAH 时处于 DAH 第 10 百分位以下的患者比例,以及在 DAH 和 DAH 时仍处于该组的患者比例。
与男性相比,女性的 DAH 较低(22 天 vs. 23 天),并且在所有手术组中均可见(单纯 CABG 23 天 vs. 24 天,单纯非 CABG 22 天 vs. 23 天,联合手术 19 天 vs. 21 天)。临床危险因素,包括合并症、社会经济地位和手术复杂性与较低的 DAH 值相关,但女性的 DAH 值比男性低,这与许多因素有关。在 DAH 处于最低 10 百分位的患者中,女性和男性分别有 80%和 72%在 90 天仍处于最低 10 百分位,而女性和男性分别有 76%和 80%在 180 天仍处于该百分位。
DAH 是对患者和手术风险因素差异的敏感反应。需要进一步研究以确定新的护理途径,以减少男性和女性患者之间的结果差异。