Chan Wai-Sing, Ho Christy Wing-Yiu, Chan Tsz-Ching, Hung Jeffrey, To Man-Yan, Leung Sau-Man, Lai Ka-Chun, Wong Ching-Yan, Leung Chin-Pang, Au Chun-Hang, Wan Thomas Shek-Kong, Zee Jonpaul Sze-Tsing, Ma Edmond Shiu-Kwan, Tang Bone Siu-Fai
Department of Pathology, Hong Kong Sanatorium & Hospital, Hong Kong SAR, China.
Viruses. 2024 Apr 13;16(4):600. doi: 10.3390/v16040600.
The BIOFIRE SPOTFIRE Respiratory (R) Panel is a novel, in vitro diagnostic PCR assay with 15 pathogen targets. The runtime is about 15 min which is the shortest among similar panels in the market. We evaluated the performance of the SPOTFIRE R Panel with 151 specimens, including 133 collected from the upper respiratory tract (URT), 13 from the lower respiratory tract (LRT) and 5 external quality assessment program (EQAP) samples. The respiratory specimens were enrolled throughout the first two post-COVID-19 influenza seasons in Hong Kong (March to December 2023). For URT specimens, full concordance was observed between the SPOTFIRE R Panel and the standard-of-care FilmArray Respiratory 2.1 Panel (RP2.1) for 109 specimens (109/133, 81.95%). After discrepant analysis, the SPOTFIRE R Panel identified more pathogens than the RP2.1 in 15 specimens and vice versa in 3 specimens. The per-target negative and positive percentage agreement (NPA and PPA) were 92.86-100% except the PPA of adenovirus (88.24%). For LRT and EQAP samples, all results were fully concordant. To conclude, the performance of the SPOTFIRE R Panel was comparable to the RP2.1.
BioFire SPOTFIRE呼吸道检测板是一种新型的体外诊断聚合酶链反应检测方法,可检测15种病原体靶点。检测时长约15分钟,是市场上同类检测板中最短的。我们用151份样本评估了SPOTFIRE呼吸道检测板的性能,其中包括133份从上呼吸道(URT)采集的样本、13份从下呼吸道(LRT)采集的样本以及5份外部质量评估计划(EQAP)样本。呼吸道样本取自香港新冠疫情后的前两个流感季节(2023年3月至12月)。对于上呼吸道样本,在109份样本(109/133,81.95%)中,SPOTFIRE呼吸道检测板与标准护理FilmArray呼吸道2.1检测板(RP2.1)结果完全一致。经过差异分析,SPOTFIRE呼吸道检测板在15份样本中检测出的病原体比RP2.1多,在3份样本中则相反。除腺病毒的阳性百分比一致性(PPA)为88.24%外,每个靶点的阴性和阳性百分比一致性(NPA和PPA)为92.86 - 100%。对于下呼吸道样本和EQAP样本,所有结果完全一致。总之,SPOTFIRE呼吸道检测板的性能与RP2.1相当。