Department of Industrial Engineering and Management, Ariel University, Ariel, Israel.
BMC Psychol. 2024 Apr 30;12(1):245. doi: 10.1186/s40359-024-01750-5.
Decision-making under uncertainty, a cornerstone of human cognition, is encapsulated by the "secretary problem" in optimal stopping theory. Our study examines this decision-making challenge, where participants are required to sequentially evaluate and make irreversible choices under conditions that simulate cognitive overload. We probed neurophysiological responses by engaging 27 students in a secretary problem simulation while undergoing EEG monitoring, focusing on Event-Related Potentials (ERPs) P200 and P400, and Theta to Beta Ratio (TBR) dynamics.Results revealed a nuanced pattern: the P200 component's amplitude declined from the initial to the middle offers, suggesting a diminishing attention span as participants grew accustomed to the task. This attenuation reversed at the final offer, indicating a heightened cognitive processing as the task concluded. In contrast, the P400 component's amplitude peaked at the middle offer, hinting at increased cognitive evaluation, and tapered off at the final decision. Additionally, TBR dynamics illustrated a fluctuation in attentional control and emotional regulation throughout the decision-making sequence, enhancing our understanding of the cognitive strategies employed.The research elucidates the dynamic interplay of cognitive processes in high-stakes environments, with neurophysiological markers fluctuating significantly as participants navigated sequential choices. By correlating these fluctuations with decision-making behavior, we provide insights into the evolving strategies from heightened alertness to strategic evaluation. Our findings offer insights that could inform the use of neurophysiological data in the development of decision-making frameworks, potentially contributing to the practical application of cognitive research in real-life contexts.
在不确定情况下进行决策是人类认知的基石,这一概念在最优停止理论的“秘书问题”中得到了体现。我们的研究考察了这种决策挑战,参与者需要在模拟认知过载的条件下,依次评估并做出不可逆转的选择。我们通过让 27 名学生在进行脑电图监测的同时参与秘书问题模拟,探究了神经生理反应,重点关注事件相关电位(ERP)P200 和 P400 以及θ波到β波的比值(TBR)动态。
P200 成分的振幅从最初的出价到中间的出价逐渐下降,这表明参与者对任务的注意力持续时间随着他们逐渐熟悉任务而缩短。这种衰减在最后一次出价时逆转,表明随着任务的结束,认知处理过程得到了提高。相比之下,P400 成分的振幅在中间出价时达到峰值,暗示着认知评估的增加,并在最后决策时逐渐减弱。此外,TBR 动态表明在整个决策过程中注意力控制和情绪调节的波动,增强了我们对所采用的认知策略的理解。
该研究阐明了在高风险环境中认知过程的动态相互作用,参与者在进行顺序选择时,神经生理标志物会发生显著波动。通过将这些波动与决策行为相关联,我们深入了解了从高度警觉到策略评估的不断演变的策略。我们的发现为将神经生理数据应用于决策框架的开发提供了启示,这可能有助于将认知研究的实际应用于现实生活情境。