Ismail Noor Akmal Shareela, Mageswaran Nanthini, Bujang Siti Mariam, Awang Besar Mohd Nasri
Department of Biochemistry, Faculty of Medicine, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Department of Medical Education, Faculty of Medicine, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Front Med (Lausanne). 2024 Apr 18;11:1375982. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2024.1375982. eCollection 2024.
Effective doctor-patient relationships hinge on robust communication skills, with non-verbal communication techniques (NVC) often overlooked, particularly in online synchronous interactions. This study delves into the exploration of NVC types during online feedback sessions for communication skill activities in a medical education module.
A cohort of 100 first-year medical students and 10 lecturers at the Faculty of Medicine, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia (UKM), engaged in communication skills activities via Microsoft Teams. Sessions were recorded, and lecturer NVC, encompassing body position, facial expressions, voice intonation, body movements, eye contact, and paralinguistics, were meticulously observed. Following these sessions, students provided reflective writings highlighting their perceptions of the feedback, specifically focusing on observed NVC.
The study identified consistent non-verbal communication patterns during feedback sessions. Lecturers predominantly leaned forward and toward the camera, maintained direct eye contact, and exhibited dynamic voice intonation. They frequently engaged in tactile gestures and paused to formulate thoughts, often accompanied by filler sounds like "um" and "okay." This consistency suggests proficient use of NVC in providing synchronous online feedback. Less observed NVC included body touching and certain paralinguistic cues like long sighs. Initial student apprehension, rooted in feelings of poor performance during activities, transformed positively upon observing the lecturer's facial expressions and cheerful intonation. This transformation fostered an open reception of feedback, motivating students to address communication skill deficiencies. Additionally, students expressed a preference for comfortable learning environments to alleviate uncertainties during feedback reception. Potential contrivances in non-verbal communication (NVC) due to lecturer awareness of being recorded, a small sample size of 10 lecturers limiting generalizability, a focus solely on preclinical lecturers, and the need for future research to address these constraints and explore diverse educational contexts.
Medical schools globally should prioritize integrating NVC training into their curricula to equip students with essential communication skills for diverse healthcare settings. The study's findings serve as a valuable reference for lecturers, emphasizing the importance of employing effective NVC during online feedback sessions. This is crucial as NVC, though occurring online synchronously, remains pivotal in conveying nuanced information. Additionally, educators require ongoing professional development to enhance proficiency in utilizing NVC techniques in virtual learning environments. Potential research directions stemming from the study's findings include longitudinal investigations into the evolution of NVC patterns, comparative analyses across disciplines, cross-cultural examinations, interventions to improve NVC skills, exploration of technology's role in NVC enhancement, qualitative studies on student perceptions, and interdisciplinary collaborations to deepen understanding of NVC in virtual learning environments.
有效的医患关系取决于强大的沟通技巧,非语言沟通技巧(NVC)常常被忽视,尤其是在在线同步互动中。本研究深入探讨了医学教育模块中沟通技巧活动在线反馈环节中的非语言沟通技巧类型。
马来西亚国民大学(UKM)医学院的100名一年级医学生和10名讲师通过Microsoft Teams参与了沟通技巧活动。课程被录制下来,讲师的非语言沟通技巧,包括身体姿势、面部表情、语调、身体动作、眼神交流和辅助语言,都被仔细观察。课程结束后,学生们撰写了反思性文章,突出了他们对反馈的看法,特别关注观察到的非语言沟通技巧。
该研究确定了反馈环节中一致的非语言沟通模式。讲师们主要向前倾并面向摄像头,保持直接的眼神交流,并表现出富有活力的语调。他们经常使用触觉手势并停顿以组织思路,常常伴随着“嗯”和“好的”等填充音。这种一致性表明在提供同步在线反馈时熟练运用了非语言沟通技巧。较少观察到的非语言沟通技巧包括身体接触和某些辅助语言线索,如长叹。最初学生的担忧源于活动期间表现不佳的感觉,但在观察到讲师的面部表情和愉快的语调后积极转变。这种转变促进了对反馈的开放接受,激励学生解决沟通技巧缺陷。此外,学生们表示更喜欢舒适的学习环境,以减轻接受反馈时的不确定性。由于讲师意识到被录制可能导致非语言沟通技巧(NVC)出现人为因素,10名讲师的小样本量限制了普遍性,仅关注临床前讲师,以及未来研究需要解决这些限制并探索不同教育背景。
全球医学院校应优先将非语言沟通技巧培训纳入课程,以使学生具备在各种医疗环境中必备的沟通技巧。该研究结果为讲师提供了有价值的参考,强调了在在线反馈环节中运用有效非语言沟通技巧的重要性。这至关重要,因为非语言沟通技巧虽然是在在线同步环境中发生,但在传达细微信息方面仍然至关重要。此外,教育工作者需要持续的专业发展,以提高在虚拟学习环境中运用非语言沟通技巧的能力。该研究结果产生的潜在研究方向包括对非语言沟通技巧模式演变的纵向调查、跨学科的比较分析、跨文化研究、提高非语言沟通技巧的干预措施、探索技术在增强非语言沟通技巧中的作用、关于学生看法的定性研究以及跨学科合作,以加深对虚拟学习环境中非语言沟通技巧的理解。