Nguyen Khoa, Shin Jordan Gawon, Andrusaitis Jessica
University of California, Irvine, Department of Emergency Medicine, Orange, CA.
University of California, Irvine, School of Medicine, Irvine, CA.
J Educ Teach Emerg Med. 2024 Apr 30;9(2):T1-T39. doi: 10.21980/J8BP90. eCollection 2024 Apr.
The target audiences for this team-based learning (TBL) activity are resident physicians and medical students.
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), nearly half of the adults in the United States have hypertension,1 which is a leading cause of cardiovascular disease and premature death.2 In extreme cases, patients may present in hypertensive emergencies, defined as an acute, marked elevation of systolic blood pressure >180mmHg or diastolic blood pressure >120mmHg with evidence of organ dysfunction.3,4 Patients presenting to the emergency department (ED) with symptoms of hypertensive emergencies must be promptly diagnosed and treated to prevent further morbidity and mortality. This TBL utilizes four clinical cases to educate resident physicians and medical students not only on the recognition of hypertensive emergencies, but also on the workup, management, and disposition of patients who present to the ED with hypertension.
By the end of this TBL session, learners should be able to: 1) define features of asymptomatic hypertension versus hypertensive emergency, 2) discuss which patients with elevated blood pressure may require further diagnostic workup and intervention, 3) identify a differential diagnosis for patients presenting with elevated blood pressures, 4) recognize the features of different types of end-organ damage, 5) review an algorithm for the pharmacologic management of hypertensive emergencies, 6) indicate dosing and routes of various anti-hypertensive medications, 7) choose the appropriate treatment for a patient who is hypertensive and presenting with flash pulmonary edema, 8) identify an aortic dissection on computed tomography (CT), 9) choose the appropriate treatment for a patient who is hypertensive and presenting with an aortic dissection, 10) identify intracranial hemorrhage on CT, 11) choose the appropriate treatment for a patient who is hypertensive and presenting with an intracranial hemorrhage, and 12) describe the intervention for warfarin reversal.
This is a classic TBL that includes an individual readiness assessment test (iRAT), a multiple-choice group readiness assessment test (gRAT), and a group application exercise (GAE).
Learners and instructors were given the opportunity to provide verbal feedback after completion of the TBL. Learners included senior medical students and first-, second-, and third-year emergency-medicine residents. Learners were specifically asked if they felt the cases were educational, relevant, and useful to their training.
Six resident physicians and three medical students volunteered their verbal feedback, and agreed when they were specifically asked if the cases were educational, relevant, and useful to their training. The same learners also agreed when asked if they felt the TBL was a more enjoyable activity than a direct lecture to refresh their knowledge and skills. One instructor observed that interns and medical students were generally able to reach a correct diagnosis; however, they seemed to struggle more with describing appropriate pharmacologic interventions when compared to more senior learners.
Hypertension is a common complaint and incidental finding in patients presenting to the ED. Given its non-specific value, it can be a difficult topic for the novice healthcare provider to master. The differential diagnosis for a patient presenting with hypertension is vast, ranging from benign to emergent, and can sometimes necessitate minimal to substantial workups. Thus, this TBL is a useful, relevant, and effective exercise for residents-in-training to review and understand the management of hypertension.
Hypertension, hypertensive emergency, asymptomatic hypertension, flash pulmonary edema, aortic dissection, intracranial hemorrhage, warfarin reversal, team-based learning.
本次基于团队的学习(TBL)活动的目标受众是住院医师和医学生。
根据疾病控制与预防中心(CDC)的数据,美国近一半的成年人患有高血压,这是心血管疾病和过早死亡的主要原因之一。在极端情况下,患者可能会出现高血压急症,定义为收缩压急性显著升高>180mmHg或舒张压>120mmHg,并伴有器官功能障碍的证据。因高血压急症症状前往急诊科(ED)就诊的患者必须迅速得到诊断和治疗,以预防进一步的发病和死亡。本次TBL利用四个临床病例,不仅对住院医师和医学生进行高血压急症的识别教育,还包括对因高血压前往ED就诊患者的检查、管理和处置教育。
在本次TBL课程结束时,学习者应能够:1)定义无症状高血压与高血压急症的特征;2)讨论哪些血压升高的患者可能需要进一步的诊断检查和干预;3)确定血压升高患者的鉴别诊断;4)识别不同类型终末器官损伤的特征;5)回顾高血压急症药物治疗的算法;6)指出各种抗高血压药物的剂量和给药途径;7)为患有高血压并伴有急性肺水肿的患者选择合适的治疗方法;8)在计算机断层扫描(CT)上识别主动脉夹层;9)为患有高血压并伴有主动脉夹层的患者选择合适的治疗方法;10)在CT上识别颅内出血;11)为患有高血压并伴有颅内出血的患者选择合适的治疗方法;12)描述华法林逆转的干预措施。
这是一个经典的TBL,包括个人准备评估测试(iRAT)、多项选择题小组准备评估测试(gRAT)和小组应用练习(GAE)。
在TBL完成后,学习者和教师有机会提供口头反馈。学习者包括高年级医学生和急诊医学专业的一年级、二年级和三年级住院医师。特别询问学习者他们是否认为这些病例对他们的培训具有教育意义、相关性和实用性。
六名住院医师和三名医学生自愿提供了口头反馈,并在被特别询问这些病例对他们的培训是否具有教育意义、相关性和实用性时表示同意。当被问及他们是否认为TBL比直接讲座更有趣,能让他们更新知识和技能时,同样的学习者也表示同意。一位教师观察到,实习生和医学生通常能够做出正确的诊断;然而,与高年级学习者相比,他们在描述适当的药物干预措施时似乎更困难。
高血压是前往ED就诊患者的常见主诉和偶然发现。鉴于其非特异性,对于新手医疗服务提供者来说,这可能是一个难以掌握的主题。高血压患者的鉴别诊断范围很广,从良性到急症,有时可能需要进行最少到大量的检查。因此,本次TBL对于住院医师培训来说是一次有用、相关且有效的练习,有助于他们复习和理解高血压的管理。
高血压、高血压急症、无症状高血压、急性肺水肿、主动脉夹层、颅内出血、华法林逆转、基于团队的学习。