Tostain Jean-Baptiste, Mathieu Marina, Oude Engberink Agnès, Clary Bernard, Amouyal Michel, Lognos Béatrice, Demoly Pascal, Annesi-Maesano Isabella, Ninot Grégory, Molinari Nicolas, Richard Arnaud, Badreddine Maha, Duflos Claire, Carbonnel Francois
Desbrest Institute of Epidemiology and Public Health, University of Montpellier, National Institute for Health and Medical Research, Montpellier, France.
Departement of General Practice, University of Montpellier, Montpellier, France.
JMIR Form Res. 2024 May 9;8:e56130. doi: 10.2196/56130.
Environmental and behavioral factors are responsible for 12.6 million deaths annually and contribute to 25% of deaths and chronic diseases worldwide. Through the One Health initiative, the World Health Organization and other international health organizations plan to improve these indicators to create healthier environments by 2030. To meet this challenge, training primary care professionals should be the priority of national policies. General practitioners (GPs) are ready to become involved but need in-depth training to gain and apply environmental health (EH) knowledge to their practice. In response, we designed the Primary Care Environment and Health (PCEH) online course in partnership with the Occitanie Regional Health Agency in France. This course was used to train GP residents from the Montpelier-Nimes Faculty of Medicine in EH knowledge. The course was organized in 2 successive parts: (1) an asynchronous e-learning modular course focusing on EH knowledge and tools and (2) 1 day of face-to-face sessions.
This study assessed the impact of the e-learning component of the PCEH course on participants' satisfaction, knowledge, and behavior changes toward EH.
This was a pilot before-and-after study. Four modules were available in the 6-hour e-learning course: introduction to EH, population-based approach (mapping tools and resources), clinical cases, and communication tools. From August to September 2021, we recruited first-year GP residents from the University of Montpellier (N=130). Participants' satisfaction, knowledge improvements for 19 EH risks, procedure to report EH risks to health authorities online, and behavior change (to consider the possible effects of the environment on their own and their patients' health) were assessed using self-reported questionnaires on a Likert scale (1-5). Paired Student t tests and the McNemar χ test were used to compare quantitative and qualitative variables, respectively, before and after the course.
A total of 74 GP residents completed the e-learning and answered the pre- and posttest questionnaires. The mean satisfaction score was 4.0 (SD 0.9) out of 5. Knowledge scores of EH risks increased significantly after the e-learning course, with a mean difference of 30% (P<.001) for all items. Behavioral scores improved significantly by 18% for the participant's health and by 26% for patients' health (P<.001). These improvements did not vary significantly according to participant characteristics (eg, sex, children, place of work).
The e-learning course improved knowledge and behavior related to EH. Further studies are needed to assess the impact of the PCEH course on clinical practice and potential benefits for patients. This course was designed to serve as a knowledge base that could be reused each year with a view toward sustainability. This course will integrate new modules and will be adapted to the evolution of EH status indicators and target population needs.
环境和行为因素每年导致1260万人死亡,占全球死亡人数和慢性病的25%。通过“同一健康”倡议,世界卫生组织和其他国际卫生组织计划到2030年改善这些指标,以创造更健康的环境。为应对这一挑战,培训初级保健专业人员应成为国家政策的优先事项。全科医生(GP)愿意参与其中,但需要深入培训以获取环境卫生(EH)知识并将其应用于实践。作为回应,我们与法国奥克西塔尼地区卫生局合作设计了初级保健环境与健康(PCEH)在线课程。该课程用于培训蒙彼利埃-尼姆医学院的全科医生住院医师的环境卫生知识。该课程分为连续两个部分:(1)一个异步电子学习模块化课程,重点是环境卫生知识和工具;(2)为期1天的面对面课程。
本研究评估了PCEH课程电子学习部分对参与者对环境卫生的满意度、知识和行为变化的影响。
这是一项前后对照的试点研究。在6小时的电子学习课程中有四个模块:环境卫生导论、基于人群的方法(地图绘制工具和资源)、临床案例和沟通工具。2021年8月至9月,我们招募了蒙彼利埃大学的一年级全科医生住院医师(N = 130)。使用李克特量表(1 - 5)的自我报告问卷评估参与者的满意度、对19种环境卫生风险的知识改善、向卫生当局在线报告环境卫生风险的程序以及行为变化(考虑环境对自身和患者健康的可能影响)。配对学生t检验和麦克内马尔χ检验分别用于比较课程前后的定量和定性变量。
共有74名全科医生住院医师完成了电子学习并回答了课前和课后问卷。平均满意度得分为4.0(标准差0.9)(满分5分)。电子学习课程后,环境卫生风险的知识得分显著提高,所有项目的平均差异为30%(P <.001)。参与者自身健康的行为得分显著提高了18%,患者健康的行为得分显著提高了26%(P <.001)。这些改善在参与者特征(如性别、是否有孩子、工作地点)方面没有显著差异。
电子学习课程改善了与环境卫生相关的知识和行为。需要进一步研究来评估PCEH课程对临床实践的影响以及对患者的潜在益处。本课程旨在作为一个知识库,为了可持续性每年都可重复使用。该课程将整合新的模块,并将根据环境卫生状况指标和目标人群需求的演变进行调整。