From the Department of Quality and Education, Bispebjerg and Frederiksberg University Hospital, Copenhagen NV, Denmark.
Danish Society for Patient Safety, Frederiksberg, Denmark.
J Patient Saf. 2024 Aug 1;20(5):e78-e84. doi: 10.1097/PTS.0000000000001242. Epub 2024 May 14.
For over 30 years, quality improvement (QI) methods have been used as a means of increasing the quality and safety of healthcare services, but with mixed success. One explanation highlighted in the literature for this outcome is the overemphasis on technical elements of change, and a failure to fully appreciate the human side of change. Behavioral insights (BI) is an approach that utilizes knowledge and tools from a broad range of scientific disciplines, such as neuroscience and behavioral psychology, to support behavior change. The aim of this paper is to explore the possibility of supplementing QI methods with tools and understanding from BI.
We outline a practical case that involved applying aspects BI methods into a QI program aimed at reducing the use of intravenous antibiotics in patients accessing services at a busy university hospital in Copenhagen, Denmark. We exemplify how to use BI tools to guide the analysis of staff behaviors during standard clinical processes and develop targeted interventions aimed at increasing actions and behaviors more aligned to best clinical practice.
Outcomes suggest that it is possible to combine the models and methods from BI and QI in a way that is helpful in focusing attention on the human side of change when developing strategies for change. Potential psychological barriers identified from the analysis included the following: 'default inertia,' 'decision complexity,' 'risk aversion,' and biases related to confidence, confirmation, and omission.
Future quality improvement projects could benefit from integrating models and tools from BI to guide and support behavior change.
30 多年来,质量改进(QI)方法一直被用作提高医疗保健服务质量和安全性的手段,但结果喜忧参半。文献中强调的一个解释是,过于强调变革的技术要素,而未能充分理解变革的人为因素。行为洞察(BI)是一种利用神经科学和行为心理学等广泛科学学科的知识和工具来支持行为改变的方法。本文旨在探讨用 BI 的工具和理解来补充 QI 方法的可能性。
我们概述了一个实际案例,该案例将 BI 方法的某些方面应用于丹麦哥本哈根一所繁忙大学医院的 QI 计划,旨在减少静脉使用抗生素的患者数量。我们举例说明了如何使用 BI 工具来指导对标准临床流程中的员工行为进行分析,并制定有针对性的干预措施,以增加更符合最佳临床实践的行动和行为。
结果表明,将 BI 和 QI 的模型和方法结合起来是有可能的,这有助于在制定变革策略时关注变革的人为因素。从分析中确定的潜在心理障碍包括:“默认惯性”、“决策复杂性”、“风险规避”以及与信心、确认和遗漏相关的偏见。
未来的质量改进项目可以从整合 BI 的模型和工具中受益,以指导和支持行为改变。