Salajegheh Mahla
Department of Medical Education, Medical Education Development Center, Kerman University of Medical Sciences, Kerman, Iran.
J Educ Health Promot. 2024 Apr 29;13:126. doi: 10.4103/jehp.jehp_308_23. eCollection 2024.
Educational program evaluation is a complex issue, and it is essential to have knowledge of the potential challenges and solutions during the whole process. The present study aimed to identify the influential components in planning, implementation, and evaluation management of educational programs in medical sciences and then provide an applied guide to guarantee the best possible evaluation by evaluators of educational programs.
This descriptive study was conducted in three steps. First, the effective components in planning, implementation, and evaluation management of educational programs in medical sciences were reviewed. Second, experts' opinion was asked through a focus group discussion regarding the mentioned components. Third, regarding the complied applied guide, the opinions of 40 medical educationist and program evaluation experts were investigated using a checklist.
An applied guide for planning, implementation, and evaluation management of educational programs in medical sciences consists of eight stages: determining the evaluation questions and standards, determining the type of information required, determining resources to collect information, determining methods and tools to collect information, determining data analysis methods, determining the timing and frequency of reporting, determining the appropriate ways of reporting, and determining strategies to maintain the cooperation of data sources.
The spread of educational programs in medical sciences universities leads to an increasing need for program evaluation to provide evidence of their effectiveness and improvement. The present research provided an applied guide to make the evaluation of educational programs feasible by using a set of concepts, principles, methods, theories, and models.
教育项目评估是一个复杂的问题,在整个过程中了解潜在挑战和解决方案至关重要。本研究旨在确定医学教育项目规划、实施和评估管理中的影响因素,然后提供一份应用指南,以确保教育项目评估人员能够进行尽可能最佳的评估。
本描述性研究分三个步骤进行。首先,回顾医学教育项目规划、实施和评估管理中的有效因素。其次,通过焦点小组讨论就上述因素征求专家意见。第三,针对编写的应用指南,使用清单对40名医学教育工作者和项目评估专家的意见进行调查。
医学教育项目规划、实施和评估管理的应用指南包括八个阶段:确定评估问题和标准、确定所需信息类型、确定收集信息的资源、确定收集信息的方法和工具、确定数据分析方法、确定报告的时间和频率、确定合适的报告方式以及确定维持数据源合作的策略。
医学科学大学中教育项目的普及导致对项目评估的需求不断增加,以证明其有效性和改进情况。本研究提供了一份应用指南,通过使用一组概念、原则、方法、理论和模型,使教育项目评估变得可行。