Medical Sciences Division, University of Oxford, UK.
Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, UK.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2024 Nov;106(8):705-710. doi: 10.1308/rcsann.2024.0028. Epub 2024 May 24.
Medical students often hesitate to enter the operating theatre because of poor visibility of the surgical field and anxiety about the theatre environment. In addition, ear, nose and throat (ENT) surgery is underrepresented in many medical curricula. Virtual systems like Proximie offer flexible viewing of surgeries with surgeon commentary, potentially addressing these issues.
This descriptive survey study aimed to evaluate the use of Proximie as a surgical education tool for delivering ENT teaching to medical students. Live ENT procedures were recorded at the ENT Department of the John Radcliffe Hospital and shared with interested clinical medical students through Proximie accounts. Students were added to a private group chat to ask questions and provided feedback through structured forms, assessing procedural effectiveness and the platform's technology. Live-streaming and recording of procedures were facilitated by ENT surgeons providing commentary.
Conducted over four virtual theatre days, the study gathered 52 responses: 96% of students rated Proximie's educational value as 4 of 5 or higher; 57% preferred the virtual experience over physical attendance because of its convenience and the improved view of the surgical field. Students valued the live commentary and showed interest in using Proximie for a broader range of surgeries. Suggested improvements included fixing technical issues, better communication of theatre lists, and expanding surgical specialty coverage.
Proximie has been highly rated by medical students for its effective and engaging approach in the instruction of surgical skills, underscoring its value as an educational tool. Future research is needed to formally assess knowledge acquisition and retention across multiple surgical subspecialties. This work is the first step towards evaluating the utility of virtual operating theatre platforms for medical student education.
由于手术视野不佳和对手术室环境的焦虑,医学生往往不愿进入手术室。此外,许多医学课程中耳鼻喉科(ENT)手术的代表性不足。Proximie 等虚拟系统提供带有外科医生解说的手术灵活观看,可能解决这些问题。
本描述性调查研究旨在评估 Proximie 作为一种手术教育工具,用于为医学生提供 ENT 教学的使用情况。在约翰拉德克利夫医院的 ENT 科记录 ENT 手术,并通过 Proximie 账户与有兴趣的临床医学生共享。学生被添加到一个私人群组聊天中,通过结构化表格提出问题并提供反馈,评估程序的有效性和平台的技术。由提供解说的 ENT 外科医生促进手术的现场直播和录制。
在四个虚拟剧院日期间进行的研究共收集了 52 份回复:96%的学生将 Proximie 的教育价值评为 4 分或更高;57%的学生更喜欢虚拟体验而不是实际出勤,因为它更方便,并且可以更好地观察手术视野。学生重视现场解说,并对使用 Proximie 进行更广泛的手术表现出兴趣。建议的改进包括解决技术问题、更好地传达手术室名单以及扩大手术专业覆盖范围。
Proximie 因其在教授手术技能方面的有效和引人入胜的方法而受到医学生的高度评价,这突显了其作为教育工具的价值。需要进一步的研究来正式评估多个外科专业的知识获取和保留情况。这项工作是评估虚拟手术室平台在医学生教育中的效用的第一步。