Edinburgh Climate Change Institute, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK.
Sustainability Research Institute, Faculty of Environment, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK.
Environ Manage. 2024 Sep;74(3):414-424. doi: 10.1007/s00267-024-01991-5. Epub 2024 May 29.
Local actors have growing prominence in climate governance but key capacities and powers remain with national policymakers. Coordination between national and local climate action is therefore of increasing importance. Underappreciated in existing academic and policy literature, coordination between actors at different scales can be affected not only by politics and institutional arrangements, but also by methods of data analysis. Exploring two datasets of GHG emissions by local area in England-one of consumption-based emissions and the other of territorial emissions-this paper shows the potential for a data scaling problem known as the modifiable areal unit problem and its possible consequences for the efficacy and equity implications of climate action. While this analysis is conceptual and does not identify specific instances of the modifiable areal unit problem or its consequences, it calls attention to methods of data analysis as possible contributors to climate governance challenges. Among other areas, future analysis is needed to explore how data scaling and other aspects of data processing and analysis may affect our understanding of non-state actors' contribution to climate action.
本地行为体在气候治理中的作用日益凸显,但关键能力和权力仍掌握在国家政策制定者手中。因此,国家和地方气候行动之间的协调变得越来越重要。在现有学术和政策文献中被低估的是,不同规模的行为体之间的协调不仅会受到政治和制度安排的影响,还会受到数据分析方法的影响。本文通过分析英格兰两个地方温室气体排放数据集——一个基于消费的排放数据集,另一个基于领土的排放数据集,展示了一个被称为可修改的面积单位问题的数据缩放问题的潜力,以及其对气候行动的效果和公平性的可能影响。虽然这种分析是概念性的,并没有确定可修改的面积单位问题或其后果的具体实例,但它提醒人们注意数据分析方法可能是气候治理挑战的一个促成因素。在其他领域,未来的分析需要探讨数据缩放以及数据处理和分析的其他方面如何影响我们对非国家行为体对气候行动的贡献的理解。