Mohd Noor Mohamad Nabil, Fatima Sahar, Grace Cockburn Jessica, Romli Muhammad Hibatullah, Pallath Vinod, Hong Wei-Han, Vadivelu Jamuna, Foong Chan Chong
Medical Education and Research Development Unit, Universiti Malaya, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
Department of Surgical Oncology, University Health Network, Toronto, Canada.
Heliyon. 2024 May 10;10(10):e31070. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e31070. eCollection 2024 May 30.
Successfully managing and utilizing feedback is a critical skill for self-improvement. Properly identifying feedback literacy level is crucial to facilitate teachers and learners especially in clinical learning to plan for better learning experience. The present review aimed to gather and examine the existing definitions and metrics used to assess feedback literacy (or parts of its concepts) for health professions education. A systematic search was conducted on six databases, together with a manual search in January 2023. Quality of the included studies were appraised using the COSMIN Checklist. Information on the psychometric properties and clinical utility of the accepted instruments were extracted. A total 2226 records of studies were identified, and 11 articles included in the final analysis extracting 13 instruments. These instruments can be administered easily, and most are readily accessible. However, 'appreciating feedback' was overrepresented compared to the other three features of feedback literacy and none of the instruments had sufficient quality across all COSMIN validity rating sections. Further research studies should focus on developing and refining feedback literacy instruments that can be adapted to many contexts within health professions education. Future research should apply a rigorous methodology to produce a valid and reliable student feedback literacy instrument.
成功管理和利用反馈是自我提升的一项关键技能。正确识别反馈素养水平对于促进教师和学习者,尤其是在临床学习中规划更好的学习体验至关重要。本综述旨在收集和审视用于评估卫生职业教育反馈素养(或其部分概念)的现有定义和指标。对六个数据库进行了系统检索,并于2023年1月进行了人工检索。使用COSMIN清单对纳入研究的质量进行评估。提取了关于所接受工具的心理测量特性和临床效用的信息。共识别出2226项研究记录,最终分析纳入11篇文章,提取出13种工具。这些工具易于管理,且大多数易于获取。然而,与反馈素养的其他三个特征相比,“欣赏反馈”的比例过高,并且没有一种工具在所有COSMIN有效性评级部分都具有足够的质量。进一步的研究应侧重于开发和完善可适应卫生职业教育多种情境的反馈素养工具。未来的研究应采用严谨的方法来制作有效且可靠的学生反馈素养工具。