Lake Shirley, Brydges Ryan, Penney Chris, Wilson Diane, Sweezie Raquel, Bagovich Maria, Bong David, Barr Susan, Stroud Lynfa
Division of Rheumatology, University of Toronto, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, 2075 Bayview Avenue, M4N3M5, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Department of Medicine, Unity Health Toronto, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Ultrasound J. 2024 May 31;16(1):30. doi: 10.1186/s13089-024-00375-4.
Point-of-care musculoskeletal (MSK) ultrasound (US) courses are typically held in-person. The COVID-19 pandemic guidelines forced courses to switch to online delivery. To determine this impact, we conducted an observational cohort study, comparing homework completion and image quality between an Online and a historical In-person cohort.
The In-person (n = 27) and Online (n = 24) cohorts attended two learning sessions spaced six months apart. The course content was the same, while the process of delivery differed. As homework, participants submitted US images biweekly for up to five months after each session. Expert faculty provided written feedback to all participants, and two independent reviewers rated the image quality for a subset of participants in each group who had completed at least 70% of their homework (In-person, n = 9; Online, n = 9). Participants self-reported their satisfaction through post-course evaluation.
63% of In-Person and 71% of Online cohort participants submitted their homework images. We observed no differences in the mean amount of homework images submitted for In-person (M = 37.3%, SD = 42.6%) and Online cohorts (M = 48.1%, SD = 38.8%; p > 0.05, Mann-Whitney U Test). At course end, the cohorts did not differ in overall image quality (p > 0.05, Wilcoxon Signed-rank Test). All participants reported high levels of satisfaction.
A convenience sample of participants attending a basic MSK US course in-person and online did not differ statistically in homework completion, quality of submitted US images, or course satisfaction. We add to literature suggesting online learning remains a viable option post-pandemic.
即时护理肌肉骨骼(MSK)超声(US)课程通常以面对面的形式进行。新冠疫情防控指南迫使这些课程改为在线授课。为了确定这种转变的影响,我们进行了一项观察性队列研究,比较了在线组和历史面对面组之间的作业完成情况和图像质量。
面对面组(n = 27)和在线组(n = 24)的参与者参加了两场间隔六个月的学习课程。课程内容相同,但授课方式不同。作为作业,参与者在每次课程结束后最多五个月内每两周提交一次超声图像。专家教员为所有参与者提供书面反馈,两名独立评审员对每组中至少完成70%作业的一部分参与者的图像质量进行评分(面对面组,n = 9;在线组,n = 9)。参与者通过课程结束后的评估自我报告他们的满意度。
面对面组63%的参与者和在线组71%的参与者提交了作业图像。我们观察到,面对面组(M = 37.3%,标准差 = 42.6%)和在线组(M = 48.1%,标准差 = 38.8%)提交的作业图像平均数量没有差异(p > 0.05,曼-惠特尼U检验)。课程结束时,两组的整体图像质量没有差异(p > 0.05,威尔科克森符号秩检验)。所有参与者都表示高度满意。
参加基础MSK超声课程的面对面组和在线组的便利样本在作业完成情况、提交的超声图像质量或课程满意度方面没有统计学差异。我们的研究补充了相关文献,表明疫情后在线学习仍然是一种可行的选择。