Avraham Guy, Ivry Richard B
Department of Psychology and Helen Wills Neuroscience Institute, University of California, Berkeley, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA.
bioRxiv. 2024 Jun 1:2024.05.27.596118. doi: 10.1101/2024.05.27.596118.
Savings refers to the gain in performance upon relearning a task. In sensorimotor adaptation, savings is tested by having participants adapt to perturbed feedback and, following a washout block during which the system resets to baseline, presenting the same perturbation again. While savings has been observed with these tasks, we have shown that the contribution from implicit sensorimotor adaptation, a process that uses sensory prediction errors to recalibrate the sensorimotor map, is actually attenuated upon relearning (Avraham et al., 2021). In the present study, we test the hypothesis that this attenuation is due to interference arising from the washout block, and more generally, from experience with a different relationship between the movement and the feedback. In standard adaptation studies, removing the perturbation at the start of the washout block results in a salient error signal in the opposite direction to that observed during learning. As a starting point, we replicated the finding that implicit adaptation is attenuated following a washout period in which the feedback now signals a salient opposite error. When we eliminated visual feedback during washout, implicit adaptation was no longer attenuated upon relearning, consistent with the interference hypothesis. Next, we eliminated the salient error during washout by gradually decreasing the perturbation, creating a scenario in which the perceived errors fell within the range associated with motor noise. Nonetheless, attenuation was still prominent. Inspired by this observation, we tested participants with an extended experience with veridical feedback during an initial baseline phase and found that this was sufficient to cause robust attenuation of implicit adaptation during the first exposure to the perturbation. This effect was context-specific: It did not generalize to movements that were not associated with the interfering feedback. Taken together, these results show that the implicit sensorimotor adaptation system is highly sensitive to memory interference from a recent experience with a discrepant action-outcome contingency.
节省指的是重新学习一项任务时在表现上的提升。在感觉运动适应中,通过让参与者适应受干扰的反馈来测试节省情况,并且在系统重置为基线的洗脱期之后,再次呈现相同的干扰。虽然在这些任务中观察到了节省现象,但我们已经表明,隐式感觉运动适应(一个利用感觉预测误差重新校准感觉运动映射的过程)在重新学习时的贡献实际上会减弱(阿夫拉罕等人,2021年)。在本研究中,我们检验了这样一个假设,即这种减弱是由于洗脱期产生的干扰,更普遍地说,是由于对运动与反馈之间不同关系的经验所导致的干扰。在标准的适应研究中,在洗脱期开始时去除干扰会导致一个与学习期间观察到的误差信号方向相反的显著误差信号。作为一个起点,我们重复了这样一个发现,即在洗脱期后隐式适应会减弱,此时反馈现在发出一个显著的相反误差信号。当我们在洗脱期消除视觉反馈时,重新学习时隐式适应不再减弱,这与干扰假设一致。接下来,我们通过逐渐减小干扰来消除洗脱期的显著误差,创造了一种情景,即感知到的误差落在与运动噪声相关的范围内。尽管如此,减弱仍然很明显。受这一观察结果的启发,我们在初始基线期让参与者有更长时间的真实反馈体验,发现这足以在首次接触干扰时导致隐式适应的强烈减弱。这种效应是特定情境的:它不会推广到与干扰反馈无关的运动上。综上所述,这些结果表明,隐式感觉运动适应系统对来自近期具有不一致动作 - 结果偶然性的经验所产生的记忆干扰高度敏感。