Department of Educational Development & Research, School of Health Professions Education, Faculty of Health, Medicine and Life Sciences, Maastricht University, Maastricht, Netherlands.
School of Health Professions Education, Department of Health Services Research, Faculty of Health, Medicine and Life Sciences, Maastricht University, Maastricht, Netherlands.
BMC Med Educ. 2024 Jun 11;24(1):647. doi: 10.1186/s12909-024-05624-7.
INTRODUCTION: Virtual Patients (VPs) have been shown to improve various aspects of medical learning, however, research has scarcely delved into the specific factors that facilitate the knowledge gain and transfer of knowledge from the classroom to real-world applications. This exploratory study aims to understand the impact of integrating VPs into classroom learning on students' perceptions of knowledge acquisition and transfer. METHODS: The study was integrated into an elective course on "Personalized Medicine in Cancer Treatment and Care," employing a qualitative and quantitative approach. Twenty-two second-year medical undergraduates engaged in a VP session, which included role modeling, practice with various authentic cases, group discussion on feedback, and a plenary session. Student perceptions of their learning were measured through surveys and focus group interviews and analyzed using descriptive statistics and thematic analysis. RESULTS: Quantitative data shows that students highly valued the role modeling introduction, scoring it 4.42 out of 5, and acknowledged the practice with VPs in enhancing their subject matter understanding, with an average score of 4.0 out of 5. However, students' reflections on peer dialogue on feedback received mixed reviews, averaging a score of 3.24 out of 5. Qualitative analysis (of focus-group interviews) unearthed the following four themes: 'Which steps to take in clinical reasoning', 'Challenging their reasoning to enhance deeper understanding', 'Transfer of knowledge ', and ' Enhance Reasoning through Reflections'. Quantitative and qualitative data are cohered. CONCLUSION: The study demonstrates evidence for the improvement of learning by incorporating VPs with learning activities. This integration enhances students' perceptions of knowledge acquisition and transfer, thereby potentially elevating students' preparedness for real-world clinical settings. Key facets like expert role modeling and various authentic case exposures were valued for fostering a deeper understanding and active engagement, though with some mixed responses towards peer feedback discussions. While the preliminary findings are encouraging, the necessity for further research to refine feedback mechanisms and explore a broader spectrum of medical disciplines with larger sample sizes is underscored. This exploration lays a groundwork for future endeavors aimed at optimizing VP-based learning experiences in medical education.
简介:虚拟患者(VP)已被证明可以改善医学学习的各个方面,然而,研究几乎没有深入探讨促进知识获取和从课堂向现实世界应用转移的具体因素。本探索性研究旨在了解将 VP 整合到课堂学习中对学生对知识获取和转移的感知的影响。
方法:该研究整合到一门关于“癌症治疗和护理中的个性化医学”的选修课程中,采用定性和定量方法。22 名二年级医学本科生参加了 VP 课程,其中包括角色建模、使用各种真实案例进行练习、小组讨论反馈和全体会议。通过问卷调查和焦点小组访谈来衡量学生对学习的看法,并使用描述性统计和主题分析进行分析。
结果:定量数据显示,学生非常重视角色建模介绍,评分为 4.42 分(满分 5 分),并承认使用 VP 来提高他们对主题的理解,平均评分为 4.0 分(满分 5 分)。然而,学生对同伴反馈对话的反思评价不一,平均得分为 3.24 分(满分 5 分)。定性分析(焦点小组访谈)揭示了以下四个主题:“临床推理的步骤”、“挑战推理以增强更深层次的理解”、“知识转移”和“通过反思增强推理”。定量和定性数据是一致的。
结论:本研究通过将 VP 与学习活动结合使用,证明了学习的改进。这种整合提高了学生对知识获取和转移的感知,从而可能提高学生对现实世界临床环境的准备程度。关键方面,如专家角色建模和各种真实案例的暴露,被认为可以促进更深入的理解和积极参与,尽管对同伴反馈讨论的反应不一。虽然初步发现令人鼓舞,但仍有必要进行进一步的研究,以完善反馈机制并探索更广泛的医学学科,扩大样本量。这项探索为旨在优化医学教育中基于 VP 的学习体验的未来努力奠定了基础。
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2015-1
BMC Med Educ. 2010-12-4
BMC Med Educ. 2018-12-6
J Med Imaging Radiat Sci. 2021-12
J Nurs Educ. 2017-5-1
IEEE Trans Vis Comput Graph. 2017-1-16
Clin Teach. 2016-4