Department of Biostatistics (J.P., N.S., A.S.), University of Washington, Seattle.
Cardiovascular Health Research Unit (J.A.B., N.S., T.D.R.), University of Washington, Seattle.
Circulation. 2024 Jul 9;150(2):102-110. doi: 10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.124.069105. Epub 2024 Jun 11.
The majority of out-of-hospital cardiac arrests (OHCAs) occur among individuals in the general population, for whom there is no established strategy to identify risk. In this study, we assess the use of electronic health record (EHR) data to identify OHCA in the general population and define salient factors contributing to OHCA risk.
The analytical cohort included 2366 individuals with OHCA and 23 660 age- and sex-matched controls receiving health care at the University of Washington. Comorbidities, electrocardiographic measures, vital signs, and medication prescription were abstracted from the EHR. The primary outcome was OHCA. Secondary outcomes included shockable and nonshockable OHCA. Model performance including area under the receiver operating characteristic curve and positive predictive value were assessed and adjusted for observed rate of OHCA across the health system.
There were significant differences in demographic characteristics, vital signs, electrocardiographic measures, comorbidities, and medication distribution between individuals with OHCA and controls. In external validation, discrimination in machine learning models (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve 0.80-0.85) was superior to a baseline model with conventional cardiovascular risk factors (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve 0.66). At a specificity threshold of 99%, correcting for baseline OHCA incidence across the health system, positive predictive value was 2.5% to 3.1% in machine learning models compared with 0.8% for the baseline model. Longer corrected QT interval, substance abuse disorder, fluid and electrolyte disorder, alcohol abuse, and higher heart rate were identified as salient predictors of OHCA risk across all machine learning models. Established cardiovascular risk factors retained predictive importance for shockable OHCA, but demographic characteristics (minority race, single marital status) and noncardiovascular comorbidities (substance abuse disorder) also contributed to risk prediction. For nonshockable OHCA, a range of salient predictors, including comorbidities, habits, vital signs, demographic characteristics, and electrocardiographic measures, were identified.
In a population-based case-control study, machine learning models incorporating readily available EHR data showed reasonable discrimination and risk enrichment for OHCA in the general population. Salient factors associated with OCHA risk were myriad across the cardiovascular and noncardiovascular spectrum. Public health and tailored strategies for OHCA prediction and prevention will require incorporation of this complexity.
大多数院外心脏骤停(OHCA)发生在普通人群中的个体中,对于这些个体,目前尚无确定的策略来识别风险。在这项研究中,我们评估了使用电子健康记录(EHR)数据来识别普通人群中的 OHCA 并确定导致 OHCA 风险的显著因素。
分析队列包括在华盛顿大学接受医疗保健的 2366 名 OHCA 患者和 23660 名年龄和性别匹配的对照者。从 EHR 中提取合并症、心电图测量、生命体征和药物处方。主要结局是 OHCA。次要结局包括可电击和不可电击的 OHCA。评估了包括接收者操作特征曲线下面积和阳性预测值在内的模型性能,并针对整个医疗系统中观察到的 OHCA 发生率进行了调整。
OHCA 患者和对照组在人口统计学特征、生命体征、心电图测量、合并症和药物分布方面存在显著差异。在外部验证中,机器学习模型的区分度(接收者操作特征曲线下面积 0.80-0.85)优于具有常规心血管危险因素的基线模型(接收者操作特征曲线下面积 0.66)。在特异性阈值为 99%的情况下,针对整个医疗系统的基线 OHCA 发生率进行校正后,机器学习模型的阳性预测值为 2.5%-3.1%,而基线模型为 0.8%。在所有机器学习模型中,较长的校正 QT 间期、物质滥用障碍、液体和电解质紊乱、酒精滥用和较高的心率被确定为 OHCA 风险的显著预测因素。已建立的心血管危险因素对可电击 OHCA 的预测仍具有重要意义,但人口统计学特征(少数民族、单身婚姻状况)和非心血管合并症(物质滥用障碍)也有助于风险预测。对于不可电击的 OHCA,确定了一系列显著的预测因素,包括合并症、习惯、生命体征、人口统计学特征和心电图测量。
在一项基于人群的病例对照研究中,纳入现成的 EHR 数据的机器学习模型显示出对普通人群中 OHCA 的合理区分度和风险富集。与 OHCA 风险相关的显著因素在心血管和非心血管范围内多种多样。公共卫生和针对 OHCA 预测和预防的针对性策略将需要纳入这种复杂性。