Clissold S P, Heel R C
Drugs. 1985 Mar;29(3):189-207. doi: 10.2165/00003495-198529030-00001.
Hyoscine (scopolamine) is a competitive inhibitor of the muscarinic receptors of acetylcholine and it has been shown to be one of the most effective agents for preventing motion sickness. However, a relatively high incidence of side effects and a short duration of action has restricted the usefulness of this agent when administered orally or parenterally, and to counter this a novel transdermal preparation of hyoscine has been developed. Pharmacokinetic studies indicate that this new method for administering hyoscine controls the absorption process and the rate of drug entry into the systemic circulation over an extended period (72 hours), providing a means of delivery which is similar to a slow intravenous infusion. However, recent evidence suggests that the response to transdermal hyoscine treatment is variable and this may reflect pharmacokinetic differences between individuals. Controlled therapeutic trials have indicated that a single transdermal hyoscine patch is significantly superior to placebo and oral meclozine (meclizine) in preventing motion sickness. Trials comparing transdermal hyoscine with oral dimenhydrinate have failed to establish any significant differences in efficacy between the 2 drugs in small numbers of subjects, although there was always a more favourable trend towards the transdermal system. In patients with acute vertigo, transdermal hyoscine and oral meclozine were equally efficacious and both were significantly better than placebo in reducing the number of attacks of vertigo. Although transdermal hyoscine has been associated with a lower incidence of side effects than orally or parenterally administered hyoscine hydrobromide, adverse systemic effects have still been frequently reported. Most commonly cited have been dry mouth, drowsiness and impairment of ocular accommodation, including blurred vision and mydriasis (some ocular effects reported may be due to finger-to-eye contamination). Adverse central nervous system (CNS) effects, difficulty in urinating, rashes and erythema have been reported only occasionally. Thus, preliminary evidence suggests transdermal hyoscine may offer an effective and conveniently administered alternative for the prevention of motion-induced nausea and vomiting in certain situations. However, the duration of its clinical effectiveness, and its relative efficacy and tolerability compared with other agents needs to be confirmed in a few additional well-designed studies.
东莨菪碱是乙酰胆碱毒蕈碱受体的竞争性抑制剂,已被证明是预防晕动病最有效的药物之一。然而,相对较高的副作用发生率和较短的作用持续时间限制了其口服或胃肠外给药的效用,为应对这一问题,已开发出一种新型东莨菪碱透皮制剂。药代动力学研究表明,这种东莨菪碱给药新方法可在较长时期(72小时)内控制吸收过程及药物进入体循环的速率,提供一种类似于缓慢静脉输注的给药方式。然而,最近的证据表明,对透皮东莨菪碱治疗的反应存在差异,这可能反映了个体间的药代动力学差异。对照治疗试验表明,在预防晕动病方面,单个透皮东莨菪碱贴片显著优于安慰剂和口服氯苯甲嗪。在少数受试者中,比较透皮东莨菪碱与口服茶苯海明的试验未能证实这两种药物在疗效上有任何显著差异,尽管透皮给药系统始终有更有利的趋势。在急性眩晕患者中,透皮东莨菪碱和口服氯苯甲嗪疗效相当,在减少眩晕发作次数方面均显著优于安慰剂。尽管与口服或胃肠外给药的氢溴酸东莨菪碱相比,透皮东莨菪碱的副作用发生率较低,但仍经常有全身不良反应的报告。最常提到的是口干、嗜睡和眼调节功能障碍,包括视力模糊和瞳孔散大(报告的一些眼部效应可能是由于手指接触眼睛造成的污染)。中枢神经系统不良反应、排尿困难、皮疹和红斑仅偶尔有报告。因此,初步证据表明,在某些情况下,透皮东莨菪碱可能为预防晕动病引起的恶心和呕吐提供一种有效且方便给药的替代方法。然而,其临床有效性的持续时间,以及与其他药物相比的相对疗效和耐受性,还需要在一些额外精心设计的研究中得到证实。