Jaiswal Abha, Núñez Carrasco Lorena, Arrow Jairo
Bronx Community College (BCC), City College of New York (CUNY), New York, NY, United States.
University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Front Sociol. 2024 May 30;9:983148. doi: 10.3389/fsoc.2024.983148. eCollection 2024.
BACKGROUND: Studies on the barriers migrant women face when trying to access healthcare services in South Africa have emphasized economic factors, fear of deportation, lack of documentation, language barriers, xenophobia, and discrimination in society and in healthcare institutions as factors explaining migrants' reluctance to seek healthcare. Our study aims to visualize some of the outcome effects of these barriers by analyzing data on maternal death and comparing the local population and black African migrant women from the South African Development Countries (SADC) living in South Africa. The heightened maternal mortality of black migrant women in South Africa can be associated with the hidden costs of barriers migrants face, including xenophobic attitudes experienced at public healthcare institutions. METHODS: Our analysis is based on data on reported causes of death (COD) from the South African Department of Home Affairs (DHA). Statistics South Africa (Stats SA) processed the data further and coded the cause of death (COD) according to the WHO classification of disease, ICD10. The dataset is available on the StatsSA website (http://nesstar.statssa.gov.za:8282/webview/) for research and statistical purposes. The entire dataset consists of over 10 million records and about 50 variables of registered deaths that occurred in the country between 1997 and 2018. For our analysis, we have used data from 2002 to 2015, the years for which information on citizenship is reliably included on the death certificate. Corresponding benchmark data, in which nationality is recorded, exists only for a 10% sample from the population and housing census of 2011. Mid-year population estimates (MYPE) also exist but are not disaggregated by nationality. For this reason, certain estimates of death proportions by nationality will be relative and will not correspond to crude death rates. RESULTS: The total number of female deaths recorded from the years 2002 to 2015 in the country was 3740.761. Of these, 99.09% ( = 3,707,003) were deaths of South Africans and 0.91% ( = 33,758) were deaths of SADC women citizens. For maternal mortality, we considered the total number of deaths recorded for women between the ages of 15 and 49 years of age and were 1,530,495 deaths. Of these, deaths due to pregnancy-related causes contributed to approximately 1% of deaths. South African women contributed to 17,228 maternal deaths and SADC women to 467 maternal deaths during the period under study. The odds ratio for this comparison was 2.02. In other words, our findings show the odds of a black migrant woman from a SADC country dying of a maternal death were more than twice that of a South African woman. This result is statistically significant as this odds ratio, 2.02, falls within the 95% confidence interval (1.82-2.22). CONCLUSION: The study is the first to examine and compare maternal death among two groups of women, women from SADC countries and South Africa, based on Stats SA data available for the years 2002-2015. This analysis allows for a better understanding of the differential impact that social determinants of health have on mortality among black migrant women in South Africa and considers access to healthcare as a determinant of health. As we examined maternal death, we inferred that the heightened mortality among black migrant women in South Africa was associated with various determinants of health, such as xenophobic attitudes of healthcare workers toward foreigners during the study period. The negative attitudes of healthcare workers toward migrants have been reported in the literature and the media. Yet, until now, its long-term impact on the health of the foreign population has not been gaged. While a direct association between the heightened death of migrant populations and xenophobia cannot be established in this study, we hope to offer evidence that supports the need to focus on the heightened vulnerability of black migrant women in South Africa. As we argued here, the heightened maternal mortality among migrant women can be considered hidden barriers in which health inequality and the pervasive effects of xenophobia perpetuate the health disparity of SADC migrants in South Africa.
背景:关于南非移民妇女在获取医疗服务时所面临障碍的研究强调了经济因素、对被驱逐的恐惧、缺乏文件、语言障碍、仇外心理以及社会和医疗机构中的歧视等因素,这些因素解释了移民不愿寻求医疗服务的原因。我们的研究旨在通过分析孕产妇死亡数据,并比较当地人口与生活在南非的来自南部非洲发展共同体(SADC)国家的黑非洲移民妇女,来直观呈现这些障碍的一些后果影响。南非黑非洲移民妇女孕产妇死亡率的升高可能与移民所面临障碍的隐性成本有关,包括在公共医疗机构中遭遇的仇外态度。 方法:我们的分析基于南非内政部(DHA)报告的死亡原因(COD)数据。南非统计局(Stats SA)对数据进行了进一步处理,并根据世界卫生组织疾病分类ICD10对死亡原因进行编码。该数据集可在StatsSA网站(http://nesstar.statssa.gov.za:8282/webview/)获取,用于研究和统计目的。整个数据集包含该国1997年至2018年期间超过1000万条记录和大约50个登记死亡变量。对于我们的分析,我们使用了2002年至2015年的数据,这期间死亡证明上可靠地包含了公民身份信息。仅在2011年人口与住房普查的10%样本中有记录国籍的相应基准数据。年中人口估计数(MYPE)也存在,但未按国籍进行分类。因此,按国籍划分的某些死亡比例估计将是相对的,且与粗死亡率不对应。 结果:2002年至2015年该国记录的女性死亡总数为3740761人。其中,99.09%(即3707003人)是南非人的死亡,0.91%(即33758人)是SADC国家女性公民的死亡。对于孕产妇死亡率,我们考虑了15至49岁女性记录的死亡总数为1530495人死亡。其中,与妊娠相关原因导致的死亡约占死亡总数的1%。在研究期间,南非女性有17228例孕产妇死亡,SADC国家女性有467例孕产妇死亡。此比较的优势比为2.02。换句话说,我们的研究结果表明,来自SADC国家的黑非洲移民妇女死于孕产妇死亡的几率是南非妇女的两倍多。这个结果在统计学上具有显著性,因为优势比2.02落在95%置信区间(1.82 - 2.22)内。 结论:本研究首次基于南非统计局2002 - 2015年可用数据,对两组女性,即SADC国家女性和南非女性的孕产妇死亡情况进行了研究和比较。该分析有助于更好地理解健康的社会决定因素对南非黑非洲移民妇女死亡率的差异影响,并将获得医疗服务视为健康的一个决定因素。在我们研究孕产妇死亡时,我们推断南非黑非洲移民妇女死亡率的升高与各种健康决定因素有关,比如在研究期间医护人员对外国人的仇外态度。医护人员对移民的负面态度已在文献和媒体中有所报道。然而,到目前为止,其对外国人群健康的长期影响尚未得到评估。虽然本研究无法确定移民人口死亡率升高与仇外心理之间的直接关联,但我们希望提供证据支持关注南非黑非洲移民妇女更高脆弱性的必要性。正如我们在此所论证的,移民妇女中孕产妇死亡率的升高可被视为一种隐性障碍,其中健康不平等和仇外心理的普遍影响使SADC移民在南非长期存在健康差距。
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2022-2-1
Asia Pac J Public Health. 1994
BMC Health Serv Res. 2017-1-31
Lancet Reg Health Am. 2022-10
Front Public Health. 2021
Matern Child Health J. 2021-2
Med Anthropol. 2019-10
Med Anthropol. 2019-4-5
BMC Public Health. 2017-7-4