School of Population and Global Health, The University of Western Australia, Perth, Western Australia, Australia.
School of Medicine and Public Health, The University of Newcastle, Callaghan, New South Wales, Australia.
PLoS Med. 2020 Mar 17;17(3):e1003061. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1003061. eCollection 2020 Mar.
Migrant women, especially from Indian and African ethnicity, have a higher risk of stillbirth than native-born populations in high-income countries. Differential access or timing of ANC and the uptake of other services may play a role. We investigated the pattern of healthcare utilisation among migrant women and its relationship with the risk of stillbirth (SB)-antepartum stillbirth (AnteSB) and intrapartum stillbirth (IntraSB)-in Western Australia (WA).
A retrospective cohort study using de-identified linked data from perinatal, birth, death, hospital, and birth defects registrations through the WA Data Linkage System was undertaken. All (N = 260,997) non-Indigenous births (2005-2013) were included. Logistic regression analysis was used to estimate odds ratios and 95% CI for AnteSB and IntraSB comparing migrant women from white, Asian, Indian, African, Māori, and 'other' ethnicities with Australian-born women controlling for risk factors and potential healthcare-related covariates. Of all the births, 66.1% were to Australian-born and 33.9% to migrant women. The mean age (years) was 29.5 among the Australian-born and 30.5 among the migrant mothers. For parity, 42.3% of Australian-born women, 58.2% of Indian women, and 29.3% of African women were nulliparous. Only 5.3% of Māori and 9.2% of African migrants had private health insurance in contrast to 43.1% of Australian-born women. Among Australian-born women, 14% had smoked in pregnancy whereas only 0.7% and 1.9% of migrants from Indian and African backgrounds, respectively, had smoked in pregnancy. The odds of AnteSB was elevated in African (odds ratio [OR] 2.22, 95% CI 1.48-2.13, P < 0.001), Indian (OR 1.64, 95% CI 1.13-2.44, P = 0.013), and other women (OR 1.46, 95% CI 1.07-1.97, P = 0.016) whereas IntraSB was higher in African (OR 5.24, 95% CI 3.22-8.54, P < 0.001) and 'other' women (OR 2.18, 95% CI 1.35-3.54, P = 0.002) compared with Australian-born women. When migrants were stratified by timing of first antenatal visit, the odds of AnteSB was exclusively increased in those who commenced ANC later than 14 weeks gestation in women from Indian (OR 2.16, 95% CI 1.18-3.95, P = 0.013), Māori (OR 3.03, 95% CI 1.43-6.45, P = 0.004), and 'other' (OR 2.19, 95% CI 1.34-3.58, P = 0.002) ethnicities. With midwife-only intrapartum care, the odds of IntraSB for viable births in African and 'other' migrants (combined) were more than 3 times that of Australian-born women (OR 3.43, 95% CI 1.28-9.19, P = 0.014); however, with multidisciplinary intrapartum care, the odds were similar to that of Australian-born group (OR 1.34, 95% CI 0.30-5.98, P = 0.695). Compared with Australian-born women, migrant women who utilised interpreter services had a lower risk of SB (OR 0.51, 95% CI 0.27-0.96, P = 0.035); those who did not utilise interpreters had a higher risk of SB (OR 1.20, 95% CI 1.07-1.35, P < 0.001). Covariates partially available in the data set comprised the main limitation of the study.
Late commencement of ANC, underutilisation of interpreter services, and midwife-only intrapartum care are associated with increased risk of SB in migrant women. Education to improve early engagement with ANC, better uptake of interpreter services, and the provision of multidisciplinary-team intrapartum care to women specifically from African and 'other' backgrounds may reduce the risk of SB in migrants.
在高收入国家,与本土出生人口相比,移民女性,尤其是来自印度和非洲裔的移民女性,死产的风险更高。获得 ANC 和其他服务的机会不同或时间不同,可能是导致这种情况的原因之一。我们调查了移民女性的医疗保健利用模式,及其与死产(产前死产和产时死产)风险之间的关系-在澳大利亚西部(WA)。
使用来自围产期、出生、死亡、医院和出生缺陷登记处的通过 WA 数据链接系统链接的匿名数据,进行了回顾性队列研究。纳入了所有(N=260997)非土著出生(2005-2013 年)。使用逻辑回归分析比较了来自白人、亚洲人、印度人、非洲人、毛利人和“其他”种族的移民女性与澳大利亚出生女性的产前死产和产时死产的优势比和 95%置信区间,同时控制了风险因素和潜在的与医疗相关的协变量。在所有分娩中,66.1%是澳大利亚出生的,33.9%是移民母亲。澳大利亚出生的母亲的平均年龄(岁)为 29.5,移民母亲的平均年龄为 30.5。在产次方面,42.3%的澳大利亚出生的女性、58.2%的印度女性和 29.3%的非洲女性是初产妇。只有 5.3%的毛利人和 9.2%的非洲移民有私人医疗保险,而澳大利亚出生的女性中有 43.1%有私人医疗保险。在澳大利亚出生的女性中,14%的人在怀孕期间吸烟,而印度和非洲背景的移民中,分别只有 0.7%和 1.9%的人在怀孕期间吸烟。与澳大利亚出生的女性相比,非洲(优势比[OR]2.22,95%置信区间 1.48-2.13,P<0.001)、印度(OR1.64,95%置信区间 1.13-2.44,P=0.013)和其他女性(OR1.46,95%置信区间 1.07-1.97,P=0.016)的产前死产风险更高,而非洲(OR5.24,95%置信区间 3.22-8.54,P<0.001)和“其他”女性(OR2.18,95%置信区间 1.35-3.54,P=0.002)的产时死产风险更高。当按首次产前检查的时间对移民进行分层时,在印度(OR2.16,95%置信区间 1.18-3.95,P=0.013)、毛利(OR3.03,95%置信区间 1.43-6.45,P=0.004)和“其他”(OR2.19,95%置信区间 1.34-3.58,P=0.002)女性中,ANC 开始时间晚于 14 周的女性,产前死产的风险增加。在只有助产士参与的分娩过程中,非洲和“其他”移民(合并)的活产儿的产时死产风险是澳大利亚出生女性的 3 倍以上(OR3.43,95%置信区间 1.28-9.19,P=0.014);然而,在多学科参与的分娩过程中,风险与澳大利亚出生组相似(OR1.34,95%置信区间 0.30-5.98,P=0.695)。与澳大利亚出生的女性相比,使用口译服务的移民女性的死产风险较低(OR0.51,95%置信区间 0.27-0.96,P=0.035);未使用口译服务的移民女性的死产风险较高(OR1.20,95%置信区间 1.07-1.35,P<0.001)。数据集中部分可用的协变量是该研究的主要局限性。
ANC 开始时间晚、口译服务利用率低以及只有助产士参与的分娩过程与移民女性的死产风险增加有关。为了降低移民的死产风险,可以对其进行教育,以提高早期参与 ANC 的机会,更好地利用口译服务,并为特别是来自非洲和“其他”背景的女性提供多学科团队的分娩护理。