Thanh Ha Nguyen, Sutrisni Ida Ayu, Rijal Samita, Pandey Aakriti, Tran Thao Phuong, Dien Ragil, Thi Hong Yen Nguyen, Timoria Diana, Friska Dewi, Kekalih Aria, Bogh Claus, Karkey Abhilasha, Hamers Raph L, Chambers Mary, Lewycka Sonia, Van Nuil Jennifer Ilo
Oxford University Clinical Research Unit, Ho Chi Minh City, Viet Nam.
Oxford University Clinical Research Unit Indonesia, Faculty of Medicine Universitas Indonesia, Jakarta, Indonesia.
SSM Qual Res Health. 2024 Jun;5:100404. doi: 10.1016/j.ssmqr.2024.100404.
Existing literature has portrayed numerous challenges that healthcare workers (HCWs) faced during the COVID-19 pandemic, such as heightened risks of transmission against the scarcity of protective equipment, burgeoning workload, and emotional distress, to name a few. However, most studies explored HCWs' experiences at the individual level rather than examining the collective responses. Exploring these experiences could reveal the social-cultural locality of the pandemic while identifying the system constraints in public health emergencies. As part of a mixed-method study on COVID-19 pandemic impacts, we analysed qualitative interview data with 129 HCWs and health-related staff to explore their experiences during the pandemic between 2020 and 2021 in Vietnam, Indonesia, and Nepal. Using Bahers' sociological framework, Community of Fate, we describe five themes reflecting the formation of a community of HCWs and the social cohesion underlying their efforts to survive hardship. The first three themes characterise the HCW community of fate, including (1) Recognition of extreme work-related danger, (2) physical and figurative closures where HCWs restrict themselves from the outside world, (3) chronic ordeals with overwhelming workload and responsibilities, encompassing recurrent mental health challenges. Against such extreme hardship, cohesive bonding and social resilience are reflected through two additional themes: (4) a mutual sense of moral and professional duty to protect communities, (5) the vertical and horizontal convergence among HCWs across levels and among government departments. We discuss these HCWs' challenges in relation to systemic vulnerabilities while advocating for increasing investment in public health and collaboration across government sectors to prepare for emergency situations.
现有文献描述了医护人员在新冠疫情期间面临的诸多挑战,比如防护设备短缺导致感染风险增加、工作量激增以及情绪困扰等等。然而,大多数研究探讨的是医护人员个人层面的经历,而非集体应对情况。探究这些经历可以揭示疫情的社会文化背景,同时找出公共卫生紧急事件中的系统制约因素。作为一项关于新冠疫情影响的混合方法研究的一部分,我们分析了对129名医护人员及卫生相关工作人员的定性访谈数据,以探究他们在2020年至2021年期间在越南、印度尼西亚和尼泊尔疫情期间的经历。运用巴尔斯的社会学框架“命运共同体”,我们描述了五个主题,这些主题反映了医护人员共同体的形成以及他们在艰难求生过程中所蕴含的社会凝聚力。前三个主题描述了医护人员的命运共同体,包括:(1)认识到与工作相关的极端危险;(2)身体和形象上的封闭,即医护人员将自己与外界隔离开来;(3)长期面临繁重的工作量和责任,包括反复出现的心理健康挑战。面对如此极端的困难,凝聚力和社会复原力通过另外两个主题得以体现:(4)保护社区的道德和职业责任感;(5)不同级别医护人员之间以及政府部门之间的纵向和横向融合。我们在倡导增加对公共卫生的投资以及政府部门间协作以应对紧急情况的同时,讨论了这些医护人员面临的与系统脆弱性相关的挑战。