Epidemiology, Biostatistics and Prevention Institute (EBPI), University of Zürich, Hirschengraben 82, Zurich, CH-8001, Switzerland.
Department of Medical Oncology, Leiden University Medical Center, Leiden, The Netherlands.
BMC Geriatr. 2024 Jun 27;24(1):563. doi: 10.1186/s12877-024-05152-5.
BACKGROUND: Breast cancer and frailty frequently co-occur in older women, and frailty status has been shown to predict negative health outcomes. However, the extent to which frailty assessments are utilized in observational research for the older breast cancer population is uncertain. Therefore, the aim of this review was to determine the frequency of use of frailty assessments in studies investigating survival or mortality, and characterize them, concentrating on literature from the past 5 years (2017-2022). METHODS: MEDLINE, EMBASE and Cochrane Library were systematically queried to identify observational studies (case-control, cohort, cross-sectional) published from 2017-2022 that focus on older females (≥ 65 years) diagnosed with breast cancer, and which evaluate survival or mortality outcomes. Independent reviewers assessed the studies for eligibility using Covidence software. Extracted data included characteristics of each study as well as information on study design, study population, frailty assessments, and related health status assessments. Risk of bias was evaluated using the appropriate JBI tool. Information was cleaned, classified, and tabulated into review level summaries. RESULTS: In total, 9823 studies were screened for inclusion. One-hundred and thirty studies were included in the final synthesis. Only 11 (8.5%) of these studies made use of a frailty assessment, of which 4 (3.1%) quantified frailty levels in their study population, at baseline. Characterization of frailty assessments demonstrated that there is a large variation in terms of frailty definitions and resulting patient classification (i.e., fit, pre-frail, frail). In the four studies that quantified frailty, the percentage of individuals classified as pre-frail and frail ranged from 18% to 29% and 0.7% to 21%, respectively. Identified frailty assessments included the Balducci score, the Geriatric 8 tool, the Adapted Searle Deficits Accumulation Frailty index, the Faurot Frailty index, and the Mian Deficits of Accumulation Frailty Index, among others. The Charlson Comorbidity Index was the most used alternative health status assessment, employed in 56.9% of all 130 studies. Surprisingly, 31.5% of all studies did not make use of any health status assessments. CONCLUSION: Few observational studies examining mortality or survival outcomes in older women with breast cancer incorporate frailty assessments. Additionally, there is significant variation in definitions of frailty and classification of patients. While comorbidity assessments were more frequently included, the pivotal role of frailty for patient-centered decision-making in clinical practice, especially regarding treatment effectiveness and tolerance, necessitates more deliberate attention. Addressing this oversight more explicitly could enhance our ability to interpret observational research in older cancer patients.
背景:乳腺癌和虚弱经常同时发生在老年女性中,虚弱状况已被证明可预测不良健康结局。然而,在观察性研究中老年乳腺癌人群中使用虚弱评估的程度尚不确定。因此,本研究的目的是确定在研究生存或死亡率的研究中使用虚弱评估的频率,并对其进行描述,重点关注过去 5 年(2017-2022 年)的文献。
方法:系统检索 MEDLINE、EMBASE 和 Cochrane Library,以确定 2017-2022 年发表的关注年龄≥65 岁、诊断为乳腺癌的老年女性的观察性研究(病例对照、队列、横断面),并评估生存或死亡率结局。独立评审员使用 Covidence 软件评估研究的合格性。提取的数据包括每项研究的特征以及研究设计、研究人群、虚弱评估和相关健康状况评估的信息。使用适当的 JBI 工具评估偏倚风险。信息进行了清理、分类和制表,以汇总到综述级别。
结果:共筛选了 9823 项研究纳入。最终有 130 项研究纳入综合分析。其中只有 11 项(8.5%)研究使用了虚弱评估,其中 4 项(3.1%)在研究人群的基线时量化了虚弱程度。对虚弱评估的描述表明,虚弱定义和患者分类(即健康、虚弱前期、虚弱)存在很大差异。在量化虚弱的四项研究中,分类为虚弱前期和虚弱的个体百分比分别为 18%至 29%和 0.7%至 21%。确定的虚弱评估包括 Balducci 评分、老年 8 项工具、适应性 Searle 缺陷累积虚弱指数、Faurot 虚弱指数和 Mian 缺陷累积虚弱指数等。Charlson 合并症指数是所有 130 项研究中使用最广泛的替代健康状况评估,使用比例为 56.9%。令人惊讶的是,所有研究中有 31.5%没有使用任何健康状况评估。
结论:很少有观察性研究纳入虚弱评估来研究老年女性乳腺癌患者的死亡率或生存结局。此外,虚弱的定义和患者分类存在显著差异。虽然共病评估更常被纳入,但虚弱在以患者为中心的临床实践中的决策中的关键作用,尤其是在治疗效果和耐受性方面,需要更慎重的关注。更明确地解决这一疏忽可以提高我们解释老年癌症患者观察性研究的能力。
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2022-2-1
Saudi J Kidney Dis Transpl. 2018
BMC Geriatr. 2018-1-26
Breast Cancer Res Treat. 2021-10
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2017-4
Breast Cancer. 2022-5