Liang Xiaoling, Ye Lu
( 610045) Department of Ultrasound, Sichuan Provincial Maternity and Child Health Care Hospital, Chengdu 610045, China.
Sichuan Da Xue Xue Bao Yi Xue Ban. 2024 May 20;55(3):749-755. doi: 10.12182/20240560208.
Cantrell syndrome, a rare congenital disorder, is characterized by a unique collection of defects on the midline abdominal wall, the lower sternum, the anterior diaphragm, and the diaphragmatic pericardium in addition to some form of intracardiac defect. So far, most of the reports on fetuses with Cantrell syndrome worldwide are either case reports or literature reviews, and few comprehensive studies on fetuses with Cantrell syndrome have been reported, especially in domestic literature. This study aims to provide a detailed analysis of 15 cases of Cantrell syndrome fetuses, focusing on their prenatal ultrasound manifestations and postnatal examination outcomes.
A retrospective analysis was conducted with 15 cases of fetuses diagnosed with Cantrell syndrome via prenatal ultrasound examinations between March 2018 and July 2023. Ultrasound examinations were performed in accordance with the Guidelines for Obstetric Ultrasound in China, including first-trimester fetal ultrasound scan and routine second-trimester fetal ultrasound scan. Gestational age was evaluated and nuchal translucency (NT) was measured during first-trimester fetal ultrasound scan at 11 to 13+6 weeks. The diagnostic criterion for NT thickening was NT≥3.0 mm and the screening of severe fetal structural malformations was performed, including the screening of the head, the neck, the thorax, the abdominal content, the abdominal wall, the limbs and other structures. During routine second-trimester fetal ultrasound scan, the fetal biometry was assessed and an anatomy survey was performed. Post-induction and postnatal outcomes of fetuses diagnosed with Cantrell syndrome by prenatal ultrasound were followed up by postnatal observation, inquiries with the electronic medical record system, or telephone follow-up. The prenatal ultrasound imaging manifestations and features of the fetuses with Cantrell syndrome, as well as their post-induction or postnatal examination results were comprehensively summarized and analyzed.
The study involved pregnant women of the average age of 30.1±3.5 years, with ultrasound diagnoses made between 11 to 26 weeks of gestation (mean: 13.4±4.0 weeks). Among the 15 cases, there were 10 singleton pregnancies and 5 cases of one twin in a pair of twins. These twins comprised 3 monochorionic diamniotic twins and 2 dichorionic diamniotic twins, with Cantrell syndrome present in one of the twins in all 5 cases. Thirteen cases were diagnosed by fetal ultrasound scan conducted in the first trimester, with 10 being singleton pregnancies and 3 being twin pregnancies (1 monochorionic diamniotic twins and 2 dichorionic diamniotic twins). One case was missed in the first-trimester ultrasound scan, resulting in a missed diagnosis rate of 7.1%. Two cases were diagnosed in second-trimester fetal ultrasound scan, both involving monochorionic diamniotic twins. One case was a referral from another hospital at 19 weeks, while the other was initially not diagnosed for Cantrell syndrome and was diagnosed at 26 weeks. Prenatal ultrasound examinations revealed a consistent pattern of abnormalities across all 15 fetuses, including manifestations of ectopic cordis combined with abdominal protrusion mass. Specifically, 4 cases were diagnosed with omphalocele, 4 with gastroschisis, and the remaining 7 had uncertain coverage of the membrane on the surface of the abdominal protrusion mass. Six fetuses had complete ectopic cordis, while nine had partial ectopic cordis. Fetal echocardiography was performed in 5 cases, revealing intracardiac malformations in 4 cases (80%). Notably, 2 cases were diagnosed in the second trimester, including one with right ventricular hypoplasia accompanied by interventricular septal defect and another with double outlet right ventricle accompanied by interventricular septal defect. Additionally, 2 cases were diagnosed in the first trimester, one with single atrium and single ventricle, and the other with complete transposition of the great arteries. Of the 15 cases of fetuses with Cantrell syndrome, 13 (86.7%) exhibited concomitant malformations in other systems. These included 7 cases of spinal malformations, 4 limb abnormalities, 3 umbilical cord abnormalities, 2 central nervous system malformations, 1 facial malformation, and 2 fetal hydrops. Spinal malformations were the most prevalent concomitant malformation, accounting for 46.7% of all cases. Among the 14 fetuses undergoing NT examination, 7 (50%) had increased NT, and 5 of them had cystic hygroma. All 10 singleton pregnancies underwent induced abortion, and the appearance of the induced fetuses was consistent with the prenatal ultrasound manifestations. In the twin pregnancies, 2 cases experienced intrauterine fetal death, while 2 underwent selective reduction. Notably, 3 of these cases exhibited postnatal appearances consistent with prenatal ultrasound manifestation, while 1 case showed an indistinct appearance after selective reduction during delivery. One case was lost to follow-up. Genetic testing was conducted for 4 induced fetuses, none of which yielded any relevant pathogenic or potentially pathogenic variants.
In conclusion, Cantrell syndrome manifests prenatally with ectopic cordis combined with abdominal protrusion mass, often accompanied by intracardiac malformations and other concomitant malformations. While most cases can be diagnosed in the first trimester, there remains the possibility of missed diagnoses, which underscores the importance of close follow-up in the second trimester.
坎特雷尔综合征是一种罕见的先天性疾病,其特征是除了某种形式的心脏内缺陷外,还在中线腹壁、下胸骨、前膈和膈心包出现独特的一系列缺陷。到目前为止,全球范围内关于患有坎特雷尔综合征胎儿的大多数报告要么是病例报告,要么是文献综述,很少有关于患有坎特雷尔综合征胎儿的综合研究报道,尤其是国内文献。本研究旨在对15例坎特雷尔综合征胎儿进行详细分析,重点关注其产前超声表现和产后检查结果。
对2018年3月至2023年7月期间通过产前超声检查诊断为坎特雷尔综合征的15例胎儿进行回顾性分析。超声检查按照中国产科超声指南进行,包括孕早期胎儿超声检查和常规孕中期胎儿超声检查。在孕11至13⁺⁶周的孕早期胎儿超声检查中评估孕周并测量颈项透明层(NT)。NT增厚的诊断标准为NT≥3.0 mm,并进行严重胎儿结构畸形的筛查,包括头部、颈部、胸部、腹腔内容物、腹壁、四肢等结构的筛查。在常规孕中期胎儿超声检查中,评估胎儿生物测量并进行解剖学检查。通过产后观察、电子病历系统查询或电话随访对产前超声诊断为坎特雷尔综合征的胎儿引产和产后结局进行随访。对患有坎特雷尔综合征胎儿的产前超声成像表现和特征及其引产或产后检查结果进行综合总结和分析。
该研究涉及平均年龄为30.1±3.5岁的孕妇,超声诊断在妊娠11至26周之间(平均:13.4±4.0周)。15例中,有10例单胎妊娠和5例双胞胎中的1个胎儿患病。这些双胞胎包括3例单绒毛膜双羊膜囊双胞胎和2例双绒毛膜双羊膜囊双胞胎,所有5例双胞胎中均有1个胎儿患有坎特雷尔综合征。13例通过孕早期胎儿超声检查诊断,其中10例为单胎妊娠,3例为双胎妊娠(1例单绒毛膜双羊膜囊双胞胎和2例双绒毛膜双羊膜囊双胞胎)。1例在孕早期超声检查中漏诊,漏诊率为7.1%。2例在孕中期胎儿超声检查中诊断,均为单绒毛膜双羊膜囊双胞胎。其中1例是在19周时从另一家医院转诊而来,另1例最初未诊断为坎特雷尔综合征,在26周时确诊。产前超声检查显示所有15例胎儿均有一致的异常模式,包括心外凸合并腹部突出肿块的表现。具体而言,4例诊断为脐膨出,4例为腹裂,其余7例腹部突出肿块表面膜的覆盖情况不确定。6例胎儿为完全性心外凸,9例为部分性心外凸。5例进行了胎儿超声心动图检查,4例(80%)发现心脏内畸形。值得注意的是,2例在孕中期诊断,其中1例为右心室发育不全伴室间隔缺损,另1例为右心室双出口伴室间隔缺损。另外,2例在孕早期诊断,1例为单心房单心室,另1例为大动脉完全转位。15例患有坎特雷尔综合征的胎儿中,13例(86.7%)在其他系统伴有畸形。这些包括7例脊柱畸形、4例肢体异常、3例脐带异常、2例中枢神经系统畸形、1例面部畸形和2例胎儿水肿。脊柱畸形是最常见的伴随畸形,占所有病例的46.7%。在接受NT检查的14例胎儿中,7例(50%)NT升高,其中5例有颈部水囊瘤。所有10例单胎妊娠均进行了引产,引产胎儿的外观与产前超声表现一致。在双胎妊娠中,2例发生宫内胎儿死亡,2例进行了选择性减胎。值得注意的是,其中3例产后外观与产前超声表现一致,1例在分娩时选择性减胎后外观不清晰。1例失访。对4例引产胎儿进行了基因检测,均未发现任何相关的致病或潜在致病变异。
总之,坎特雷尔综合征在产前表现为心外凸合并腹部突出肿块,常伴有心脏内畸形和其他伴随畸形。虽然大多数病例可在孕早期诊断,但仍有漏诊的可能性,这凸显了孕中期密切随访的重要性。