Aewerdieck Lena M, Martin Rachelle A, Graham Fiona P, Hay-Smith Jean
Department of Medicine, Rehabilitation Teaching and Research Unit, University of Otago Wellington, Wellington South, New Zealand.
J Integr Complement Med. 2024 Dec;30(12):1147-1161. doi: 10.1089/jicm.2024.0151. Epub 2024 Jul 8.
The purpose of this review was to identify and describe the evidence about children and youth engagement during equine-assisted services (EAS). Five databases (Scopus, Web of Science, PsycINFO, CINAHL, and MEDLINE) were systematically searched. Included studies reported research about EAS conducted in children and youth and presented findings about in-session engagement or associated concepts such as motivation, involvement, and participation. Extracted data (study type, equine intervention, population, and the studies' key focus) were summarized descriptively, followed by inductive content analysis of the main mechanisms proposed to influence engagement. In total, 30 studies were identified; however, only three centered on rider engagement as the primary focus of research. Other publications addressed in-session engagement within service descriptions or results and discussion sections. Three mechanisms that influence engagement within EAS were derived: (1) the unique EAS landscape, (2) the horse-child relationship and (3) the provider-child relationship. The literature primarily referred to horses as the most important factor influencing child and youth engagement in EAS sessions. Little attention was given to the influence of service providers', parents', or child preferences on engagement. The child/youth-parent-provider relational triad and specific strategies to improve rider engagement within EAS sessions warrants further investigation.
本综述的目的是识别和描述有关儿童和青少年在马术辅助服务(EAS)中的参与情况的证据。我们系统地检索了五个数据库(Scopus、科学网、心理学文摘数据库、护理学与健康领域数据库和医学期刊数据库)。纳入的研究报告了在儿童和青少年中开展的关于EAS的研究,并呈现了关于 session 期间参与情况或相关概念(如动机、参与度和参与)的研究结果。对提取的数据(研究类型、马术干预、研究对象以及研究的重点)进行了描述性总结,随后对影响参与度的主要机制进行了归纳性内容分析。总共识别出30项研究;然而,只有三项研究将骑手的参与度作为主要研究重点。其他出版物在服务描述或结果与讨论部分涉及了 session 期间的参与情况。得出了影响EAS中参与度的三个机制:(1)独特的EAS环境,(2)马与儿童的关系,以及(3)服务提供者与儿童的关系。文献主要将马视为影响儿童和青少年参与EAS课程的最重要因素。很少关注服务提供者、父母或儿童偏好对参与度的影响。儿童/青少年-父母-服务提供者关系三元组以及提高EAS课程中骑手参与度的具体策略值得进一步研究。