Department of Radiological Technology, Gunma Prefectural College of Health Sciences, Maebashi, Gunma, Japan.
PLoS One. 2024 Jul 11;19(7):e0304860. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0304860. eCollection 2024.
Optimization tasks in diagnostic radiological imaging require objective quantitative metrics that correlate with the subjective perception of observers. However, although one such metric, the structural similarity index (SSIM), is popular, it has limitations across various aspects in its application to medical images. In this study, we introduce a novel image quality evaluation approach based on keypoints and their associated unique image feature values, focusing on developing a framework to address the need for robustness and interpretability that are lacking in conventional methodologies. The proposed index quantifies and visualizes the distance between feature vectors associated with keypoints, which varies depending on changes in the image quality. This metric was validated on images with varying noise levels and resolution characteristics, and its applicability and effectiveness were examined by evaluating images subjected to various affine transformations. In the verification of X-ray computed tomography imaging using a head phantom, the distances between feature descriptors for each keypoint increased as the image quality degraded, exhibiting a strong correlation with the changes in the SSIM. Notably, the proposed index outperformed conventional full-reference metrics in terms of robustness to various transformations which are without changes in the image quality. Overall, the results suggested that image analysis performed using the proposed framework could effectively visualize the corresponding feature points, potentially harnessing lost feature information owing to changes in the image quality. These findings demonstrate the feasibility of applying the novel index to analyze changes in the image quality. This method may overcome limitations inherent in conventional evaluation methodologies and contribute to medical image analysis in the broader domain.
在诊断放射影像学中的优化任务需要与观察者的主观感知相关联的客观定量指标。然而,尽管有一种这样的指标,即结构相似性指数 (SSIM),在应用于医学图像时,它在各个方面都存在局限性。在这项研究中,我们引入了一种基于关键点及其相关独特图像特征值的新型图像质量评估方法,重点开发一种解决常规方法缺乏稳健性和可解释性的框架。所提出的指标量化并可视化了与关键点相关的特征向量之间的距离,该距离取决于图像质量的变化。该指标在具有不同噪声水平和分辨率特征的图像上进行了验证,并通过评估受到各种仿射变换的图像来检验其适用性和有效性。在对头模型的 X 射线计算机断层扫描成像的验证中,随着图像质量的下降,每个关键点的特征描述符之间的距离增加,与 SSIM 的变化具有很强的相关性。值得注意的是,与传统的全参考指标相比,该指标在对各种变换的稳健性方面表现更好,而这些变换不会改变图像质量。总体而言,结果表明,使用所提出的框架进行的图像分析可以有效地可视化相应的特征点,可能利用由于图像质量变化而丢失的特征信息。这些发现表明可以应用新的索引来分析图像质量的变化。该方法可能克服传统评估方法固有的局限性,并为更广泛的医学图像分析领域做出贡献。