Harriet Rothkopf Heilbrunn School of Nursing, Long Island University, Brooklyn Campus, Brooklyn, New York, United States of America.
Primary Care Health Services, Barnard College, New York, New York, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2024 Jul 11;19(7):e0306265. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0306265. eCollection 2024.
Perinatal depression (PND) is underdiagnosed in the clinical setting. This study explores the role of obstetricians, and other primary care providers of maternal and child healthcare in detecting, screening, and referring women during the perinatal period identified as depressed, anxious, or exhibiting other symptoms of mental health disorders.
Information was gathered from obstetricians (n = 16), and other primary care providers (pediatricians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants) (n = 85), on identifying and supporting childbearing women with symptoms of perinatal depression using an online survey.
Statistical comparisons across participant groups were adjusted for years of practice in the profession. Statistically significant differences were noted. Obstetricians inquired more about the mother's social support network (p = .011) and addressed mothers that appeared sad, upset, or unhappy (p = .044) compared to other primary care providers. Other primary care providers were more likely to refer patients to mental health support services (p = .005), provide PND-related information in their waiting rooms (p = .008), and use the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS) (p = .027). There was also a significant difference in positively identifying eight symptoms of PND between provider groups. Obstetricians had higher rates of identifying the following symptoms: excessive crying (p < .001), feeling little or no attachment to the infant (p < .001), little feeling of enjoyment (p = .021), feelings of failure (p < .001), hopelessness (p < .001), agitation with self and infant (p < .001), fear of being alone with the infant (p = .011), and fear that these symptoms would last (p < .001).
Although certain screening practices were performed well, especially by the obstetrician group, screening deficits were noted within each group, and screening practices differed between groups. Training offered to maternal child health primary care providers on addressing perinatal mental health disorders may help improve provider screening practices and detection of PND symptoms in perinatal women. PND screening that combines face-to-face open-ended interviews with standardized screening tools can enhance patient-provider communication, potentially improving PND detection rates and follow-up care in perinatal women.
围产期抑郁症(PND)在临床环境中诊断不足。本研究探讨了妇产科医生以及其他母婴保健初级保健提供者在识别、筛查和转介在围产期被诊断为抑郁、焦虑或表现出其他精神健康障碍症状的女性方面的作用。
通过在线调查,从妇产科医生(n=16)和其他初级保健提供者(儿科医生、执业护士、医师助理)(n=85)收集了有关识别和支持有围产期抑郁症状的产妇的信息。
对不同组别的参与者进行了统计学比较,并对其专业实践年限进行了调整。结果发现了统计学上的显著差异。与其他初级保健提供者相比,妇产科医生更关注母亲的社会支持网络(p=0.011),并关注那些看起来悲伤、沮丧或不开心的母亲(p=0.044)。其他初级保健提供者更有可能将患者转介到心理健康支持服务机构(p=0.005),在候诊室提供 PND 相关信息(p=0.008),并使用爱丁堡产后抑郁量表(EPDS)(p=0.027)。在确定 PND 的八种症状方面,提供者之间也存在显著差异。妇产科医生更有可能识别以下症状:过度哭泣(p<0.001)、对婴儿几乎没有或没有依恋感(p<0.001)、很少感到愉悦(p=0.021)、感到失败(p<0.001)、绝望(p<0.001)、自我和婴儿的烦躁不安(p<0.001)、害怕独自与婴儿在一起(p=0.011)和担心这些症状会持续存在(p<0.001)。
尽管某些筛查实践做得很好,尤其是妇产科医生组,但每个组内都存在筛查缺陷,而且组间的筛查实践也存在差异。为母婴保健初级保健提供者提供有关处理围产期精神健康障碍的培训可能有助于改善提供者的筛查实践,并提高围产期妇女的 PND 症状检出率。将面对面开放式访谈与标准化筛查工具相结合的 PND 筛查可以增强医患沟通,有可能提高围产期妇女的 PND 检出率和后续护理。