Nandi Tulika, Kop Benjamin R, Butts Pauly Kim, Stagg Charlotte J, Verhagen Lennart
Donders Institute for Brain Cognition and Behaviour, Radboud University, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
Department of Human Movement Sciences, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
ArXiv. 2024 Jul 3:arXiv:2407.01232v2.
Transcranial ultrasonic stimulation (TUS) is rapidly gaining traction for non-invasive human neuromodulation, with a pressing need to establish protocols that maximise neuromodulatory efficacy. In this review, we aggregate and examine empirical evidence for the relationship between tunable TUS parameters and in vitro and in vivo outcomes. Based on this multiscale approach, TUS researchers can make better informed decisions about optimal parameter settings. Importantly, we also discuss the challenges involved in extrapolating results from prior empirical work to future interventions, including the translation of protocols between models and the complex interaction between TUS protocols and the brain. A synthesis of the empirical evidence suggests that larger effects will be observed at lower frequencies within the sub-MHz range, higher intensities and pressures than commonly administered thus far, and longer pulses and pulse train durations. Nevertheless, we emphasise the need for cautious interpretation of empirical data from different experimental paradigms when basing protocols on prior work as we advance towards refined TUS parameters for human neuromodulation.
经颅超声刺激(TUS)作为一种非侵入性的人体神经调节方法正在迅速获得认可,迫切需要建立能够使神经调节效果最大化的方案。在本综述中,我们汇总并研究了可调TUS参数与体外和体内结果之间关系的实证证据。基于这种多尺度方法,TUS研究人员可以在最佳参数设置方面做出更明智的决策。重要的是,我们还讨论了将先前实证研究结果外推至未来干预措施所涉及的挑战,包括不同模型之间方案的转换以及TUS方案与大脑之间的复杂相互作用。实证证据的综合表明,在低于兆赫兹范围的较低频率、高于目前常用强度和压力以及更长脉冲和脉冲串持续时间下,将观察到更大的效果。然而,当我们朝着用于人类神经调节的精确TUS参数前进,基于先前的研究制定方案时,我们强调需要谨慎解读来自不同实验范式的实证数据。