Raj K Karthi Vignesh, Ransing Ramdas, Sethi Satyaranjan, Devraj Nilesh
Forensic Medicine, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Guwahati, Guwahati, IND.
Psychiatry, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Guwahati, Guwahati, IND.
Cureus. 2024 Jun 15;16(6):e62419. doi: 10.7759/cureus.62419. eCollection 2024 Jun.
Background Forensic Medicine (FM) is one of the core specialties of medicine in India, which serves as a bridge between medical science and India's justice delivery systems. Although FM experts play a crucial role in handling medicolegal cases, there is an increasing deficit of FM experts in India. This may be due to the inadequate postgraduate (PG) seats across the states and the low uptake of PG seats in FM. This study was conducted to explore the current status of PG seats along with the Forensic Medicine Toxicology (FMT)/FM index across Indian states. Methodology In this cross-sectional study, data on the number of PGs in FMT/FM and the institutes offering PG courses in FMT/FM were searched on the official website of the National Medical Commission. The data available on the website until November 2023 were incorporated. The FMT/FM index was calculated at the national and state levels, and the states were graded based on the national FMT/FM index. Results The national FMT/FM PG trainee index was 0.054. Considering this as the reference value, grading of the FMT/FM PG trainee index was done as the highest (1.159 to 0.308), higher than the nation (0.054 but less than 0.308), lower than the nation (0.054 but higher than 0.00), and zero. Among all the states and union territories, Andaman & Nicobar, Arunachal Pradesh, Dadra and Nagar Haveli, Jammu & Kashmir, Lakshadweep, Mizoram, Nagaland, Sikkim, and Ladakh had zero FMT/FM PG index due to non-availability of any PG seats for FMT/FM. In total, 20 states had an FMT/FM PG index higher than India's FMT/FM PG index headed by Pondicherry (1.159), followed by Chandigarh (0.429) and Goa (0.308). Conclusions PG seats were highly deficient in several states, which is more likely to affect justice delivery in the future across these states. This study has a few limitations, as we did not explore the actual intake of these PG seats across different states. We anticipate a lower intake of PG seats due to factors such as low demand, fewer job opportunities, and monetary gain. However, this needs further exploration in future studies.
背景 法医学(FM)是印度医学的核心专业之一,它是医学与印度司法系统之间的桥梁。尽管法医学专家在处理法医学案例中发挥着关键作用,但印度法医学专家的短缺却日益严重。这可能是由于各邦研究生(PG)席位不足以及法医学领域PG席位的报考率较低。本研究旨在探讨印度各邦PG席位的现状以及法医学毒理学(FMT)/法医学指数。
方法 在这项横断面研究中,我们在国家医学委员会的官方网站上搜索了FMT/法医学领域PG的数量以及提供FMT/法医学PG课程的机构的数据。纳入了截至2023年11月该网站上可用的数据。计算了国家和邦层面的FMT/法医学指数,并根据国家FMT/法医学指数对各邦进行了分级。
结果 国家FMT/法医学PG实习生指数为0.054。以该值作为参考值,将FMT/法医学PG实习生指数分级为最高(1.159至0.308)、高于全国水平(0.054但小于0.308)、低于全国水平(0.054但高于0.00)和零。在所有邦和联邦属地中,安达曼和尼科巴群岛、阿鲁纳恰尔邦、达德拉和纳加尔哈维利、查谟和克什米尔、拉克沙群岛、米佐拉姆邦、那加兰邦、锡金邦和拉达克邦的FMT/法医学PG指数为零,因为没有FMT/法医学的PG席位。总共有20个邦的FMT/法医学PG指数高于印度的FMT/法医学PG指数,其中以本地治里邦(1.159)为首,其次是昌迪加尔(0.429)和果阿邦(0.308)。
结论 几个邦的PG席位严重短缺,这很可能在未来影响这些邦的司法工作开展。本研究存在一些局限性,因为我们没有探讨不同邦这些PG席位的实际招生情况。由于需求低、工作机会少和经济收益等因素,我们预计PG席位的招生人数会较低。然而,这需要在未来的研究中进一步探讨。