Carter Bethan, Shelton Katherine H, Holmes Lisa J, Sprecher Eva A, Javed Maryam, Macleod John, Park Jeongeun, Selwyn Julie, Siraj Iram, Robinson Charlotte, Hiller Rachel M
Cardiff University, UK.
University of Sussex, UK.
Clin Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2025 Jul;30(3):611-631. doi: 10.1177/13591045251333028. Epub 2025 Apr 21.
BackgroundCare-experienced young people (CEYP) have far higher rates of mental ill-health than their peers. Less is known about their wellbeing and the overlap between mental health and wellbeing in this population. Drawing on two samples of CEYP, we explored mental health and wellbeing profiles, the overlap between these, and basic predictors of symptom severity.MethodsWe recruited two samples of CEYP: 269 10-13-year-olds and 155 16-17-year-olds, and their primary caregiver. All participants were either in local authority (out-of-home) care or had been adopted from the care system in England and Wales. Participants completed standardised measures of anxiety-, depression-, PTSD-, and externalising symptoms, as well as standardised wellbeing measures.ResultsThe majority of young people in both samples reported clinically-elevated symptomology, with mental health and wellbeing particularly poor in the late adolescents sample. Almost half of the 16-17 year old sample rated their wellbeing as poor. Overall, we found moderate associations between mental health and wellbeing. In early adolescents, these associations were less clear (many with clinically-elevated mental health reported average wellbeing), but for older teens poor mental health was closely related with the poorest reported wellbeing. There was no consistent evidence that age, gender, or ethnicity predicted wellbeing, but mental health was generally the poorest for older teens in residential care placements.ConclusionsWe found high levels of disorder-specific mental health symptomology in CEYP, with 16-17-year-olds having particularly high levels of mental health difficulties and low wellbeing. Results highlight the crucial role of early intervention and prevention in this group, before difficulties become entrenched and affect wider aspects of wellbeing.
背景
有过照料经历的年轻人(CEYP)出现心理健康问题的几率远高于同龄人。对于他们的幸福感以及该人群中心理健康与幸福感之间的重叠情况,我们了解得较少。基于两组CEYP样本,我们探究了心理健康和幸福感状况、二者之间的重叠情况以及症状严重程度的基本预测因素。
方法
我们招募了两组CEYP样本:269名10至13岁的青少年和155名16至17岁的青少年,以及他们的主要照料者。所有参与者要么处于地方当局(家庭外)照料中,要么是从英格兰和威尔士的照料系统中被收养的。参与者完成了焦虑、抑郁、创伤后应激障碍和外化症状的标准化测量,以及幸福感的标准化测量。
结果
两个样本中的大多数年轻人报告有临床水平升高的症状,其中16至17岁样本的心理健康和幸福感尤其差。16至17岁样本中近一半的人将自己的幸福感评为较差。总体而言,我们发现心理健康与幸福感之间存在中等程度的关联。在青少年早期,这些关联不太明显(许多心理健康水平升高的人报告幸福感处于平均水平),但对于年龄较大的青少年来说,心理健康状况较差与报告的最差幸福感密切相关。没有一致的证据表明年龄、性别或种族能预测幸福感,但在寄宿照料机构中的年龄较大的青少年心理健康状况通常最差。
结论
我们发现CEYP中特定障碍的心理健康症状水平较高,16至17岁的青少年心理健康困难程度尤其高,幸福感较低。结果凸显了在该群体中进行早期干预和预防的关键作用,以免困难变得根深蒂固并影响幸福感的更广泛方面。