Abdelrahman Hams H, Hamza Maha, Essam Wafaa, Adham May, AbdulKafi Abdulrahman, Baniode Mohammad
Department of Pediatric Dentistry and Dental Public Health, Faculty of Dentistry, Alexandria University, Champollion St., Azarita, 21526, Alexandria, Egypt.
Health Information Systems Programme (HISP), Middle East and North Africa (MENA), Amman, Jordan.
BMC Oral Health. 2024 Jul 16;24(1):807. doi: 10.1186/s12903-024-04550-w.
Early childhood caries (ECC) is a major global health issue affecting millions of children. Mitigating this problem requires up-to-date information from reliable surveillance systems. This enables evidence-based decision-making to devise oral health policies. The World Health Organization (WHO) advocates the adoption of mobile technologies in oral disease surveillance because of their efficiency and ease of application. The study describes developing an electronic, oral health surveillance system (EOHSS) for preschoolers in Egypt, using the District Health Information System (DHIS2) open-source platform along with its Android App, and assesses its feasibility in data acquisition.
The DHIS2 Server was configured for the DHIS2 Tracker Android Capture App to allow individual-level data entry. The EOHSS indicators were selected in line with the WHO Action Plan 2030. Two modalities for the EOHSS were developed based on clinical data capture: face-to-face and tele/asynchronous. Eight dentists in the pilot team collected 214 events using modality-specific electronic devices. The pilot's team's feedback was obtained regarding the EOHSS's feasibility in collecting data, and a time-motion study was conducted to assess workflow over two weeks. Independent t-test and Statistical Process Control techniques were used for data analysis.
The pilot team reported positive feedback on the structure of the EOHSS. Workflow adaptations were made to prioritize surveillance tasks by collecting data from caregivers before acquiring clinical data from children to improve work efficiency. A shorter data capture time was required during face-to-face modality (4.2 ± 0.7 min) compared to telemodality (5.1 ± 0.9 min), p < 0.001). The acquisition of clinical data accounted for 16.9% and 21.1% of the time needed for both modalities, respectively. The time required by the face-to-face modality showed random variation, and the tele-modality tasks showed a reduced time trend to perform tasks.
The DHIS2 provides a feasible solution for developing electronic, oral health surveillance systems. The one-minute difference in data capture time in telemodality compared to face-to-face indicates that despite being slightly more time-consuming, telemodality still shows promise for remote oral health assessments that is particularly valuable in areas with limited access to dental professionals, potentially expanding the reach of oral health screening programs.
幼儿龋齿(ECC)是一个影响数百万儿童的重大全球健康问题。缓解这一问题需要来自可靠监测系统的最新信息。这有助于基于证据做出决策,以制定口腔健康政策。世界卫生组织(WHO)倡导在口腔疾病监测中采用移动技术,因为其效率高且易于应用。本研究描述了在埃及利用地区卫生信息系统(DHIS2)开源平台及其安卓应用程序开发一个针对学龄前儿童的电子口腔健康监测系统(EOHSS),并评估其在数据采集方面的可行性。
为DHIS2追踪器安卓采集应用程序配置DHIS2服务器,以允许进行个体层面的数据录入。EOHSS指标是根据WHO 2030行动计划选定的。基于临床数据采集开发了两种EOHSS模式:面对面和远程/异步模式。试点团队中的八名牙医使用特定模式的电子设备收集了214个事件。获取了试点团队关于EOHSS在数据收集方面可行性的反馈,并进行了一项时间动作研究以评估两周内的工作流程。使用独立t检验和统计过程控制技术进行数据分析。
试点团队对EOHSS的结构给予了积极反馈。对工作流程进行了调整,通过在从儿童获取临床数据之前先从照顾者那里收集数据来优先安排监测任务,以提高工作效率。与远程模式(5.1±0.9分钟)相比,面对面模式所需的数据采集时间更短(4.2±0.7分钟),p<0.001)。两种模式下临床数据采集分别占所需时间的16.9%和21.1%。面对面模式所需时间呈现随机变化,而远程模式任务执行时间呈减少趋势。
DHIS2为开发电子口腔健康监测系统提供了一个可行的解决方案。远程模式与面对面模式相比,数据采集时间相差一分钟,这表明尽管远程模式稍耗时,但仍显示出在远程口腔健康评估方面的前景,这在获得牙科专业人员机会有限的地区尤为有价值,可能会扩大口腔健康筛查项目的覆盖范围。