Holme I, Hjermann I, Helgeland A, Leren P
Prev Med. 1985 May;14(3):279-92. doi: 10.1016/0091-7435(85)90057-x.
In this randomized, primary prevention trial of 1,232 high-risk, middle-aged Oslo men, advice during 5 years about diet and smoking brought about a significant reduction (47%) in incidence of first major coronary heart disease (CHD) events in the intervention group compared with controls. Data are presented indicating that the net difference of 10% in serum cholesterol between groups was the main cause for this achievement and that the antismoking factor, due to a rather small net difference in quit rates (17 and 24% in control and intervention groups, respectively), contributed to a lesser degree. Analysis of social class reveals that the favorable results in the intervention group were present in all social strata, despite the unexpected finding that lower class men experienced a lower CHD incidence than men of higher socioeconomic status. Antismoking advice was especially effective in lower class intervention group men. Among cigarette quitters, lower social class men reduced their serum cholesterol more than higher social class men. However, for the total intervention group, higher status men had at least as great a reduction in serum cholesterol as did lower status men. With endpoint follow-up extended to 8.5-10 years, additional cases of CHD (nonfatal and fatal myocardial infarction and sudden death) numbered 7 and 10 in the intervention and control groups, respectively; CHD cases throughout the trial totaled 25 and 45 (P approximately equal to 0.02). Total deaths numbered 19 and 31, respectively (P approximately equal to 0.05).
在这项针对1232名高危中年奥斯陆男性的随机初级预防试验中,与对照组相比,干预组在5年时间里接受的饮食和吸烟建议使首次重大冠心病(CHD)事件的发生率显著降低(47%)。所呈现的数据表明,两组之间血清胆固醇10%的净差异是这一成果的主要原因,而戒烟因素由于戒烟率的净差异较小(对照组和干预组分别为17%和24%),贡献程度较小。社会阶层分析显示,尽管有意外发现,即下层社会男性的冠心病发病率低于社会经济地位较高的男性,但干预组在所有社会阶层中都取得了良好效果。戒烟建议在下层社会干预组男性中尤其有效。在戒烟者中,下层社会男性比上层社会男性降低血清胆固醇的幅度更大。然而,对于整个干预组来说,较高地位男性的血清胆固醇降低幅度至少与较低地位男性一样大。将终点随访延长至8.5 - 10年,干预组和对照组新增冠心病病例(非致命和致命性心肌梗死及猝死)分别为7例和10例;整个试验中的冠心病病例总数分别为25例和45例(P约等于0.02)。总死亡人数分别为19例和31例(P约等于0.05)。