Wasielewska Ewelina, Kordel Piotr, Moskalewicz Marcin
Department of Nursing Practices, Poznan University of Medical Sciences, Rokietnicka 2a, 60-806 Poznań, Poland.
Department of Anesthesiology and Intensive Care, Independent Public Healthcare Center of the Ministry of Interior and Administration Prof. Ludwik Bierkowski, Dojazd 34, 60-631 Poznań, Poland.
Nurs Rep. 2024 Jul 17;14(3):1722-1734. doi: 10.3390/nursrep14030128.
The aim of this study was to comparatively investigate education, job, and professional development satisfaction among intensive care unit nurses in Poland and England. A total of 258 ICU nurses from both countries were interviewed (72 Polish nurses working in Poland and 186 of various national backgrounds in England, including 50 of Polish origin). We used an 11-item structured survey followed by an open-ended qualitative interview retrospectively coded for statistical analysis. Regardless of national origin, nurses in England report significantly higher education satisfaction, attributed to better theoretical knowledge gain but not to other dimensions (such as practical knowledge or personal satisfaction). They also express greater satisfaction with job conditions regarding professional development, a state-of-the-art work environment, teamwork, and finance. The UK system is also considered significantly superior in promotion opportunities and participation in post-graduation training. In conclusion, systemic factors play a crucial role in career satisfaction and advancement in nursing, with the British band system having a clear advantage over the Polish one.
本研究的目的是比较调查波兰和英国重症监护病房护士的教育、工作及职业发展满意度。来自两国的258名重症监护病房护士接受了访谈(72名在波兰工作的波兰护士以及186名来自不同国家背景的在英国工作的护士,其中包括50名波兰裔护士)。我们采用了一份包含11个条目的结构化调查问卷,随后进行了开放式定性访谈,并对访谈内容进行回顾性编码以进行统计分析。无论国籍如何,英国的护士对教育的满意度显著更高,这归因于更好地获取了理论知识,而非其他方面(如实践知识或个人满意度)。他们对与职业发展、先进的工作环境、团队合作及薪资相关的工作条件也表达了更高的满意度。英国体系在晋升机会和参与毕业后培训方面也被认为明显更具优势。总之,系统因素在护理职业满意度和职业发展中起着关键作用,英国的职称体系比波兰的具有明显优势。