Batek Lindsay M, Leblanc Natalie M, Alio Amina P, Stein Karen F, McMahon James M
School of Nursing, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, New York, United States of America.
Department of Public Health Sciences, School of Medicine and Dentistry, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, New York, United States of America.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2024 Jul 25;4(7):e0003169. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0003169. eCollection 2024.
Hispanic American adolescents experience high rates of pregnancy with profound consequences. Compared with White teens, Hispanic teens use contraception less frequently and often choose less effective forms of contraception. Access to contraception is a primary barrier to use which contributes to relatively high and disparate rates of pregnancy in Hispanic teens. This integrative review identifies facilitators and barriers of contraception access and use for Hispanic women, 13-17 years of age, living in the U.S.
Following the Whittemore and Knafl (2005) methodology and PRISMA guidelines, peer reviewed studies were retrieved from PUBMED, CINAHL and EMBASE. The Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool was used to assess the study quality and thematic analysis was used to categorize barriers and facilitators.
Of 131 studies retrieved, 16 met inclusion criteria. Individual, interpersonal and healthcare provider factors were identified as primary categories of barriers and facilitators with structural issues comprising an additional barrier category. Individual level barriers were disproportionately represented and further categorized into themes: beliefs/misconceptions, dislike of contraception, pregnancy risk perception, lack of knowledge, and lack of control. Barriers related to cultural and religious influences were identified in individual, interpersonal and structural levels. The most frequently reported facilitators were perceived parent comfort discussing sexual health and past experience of pregnancy.
Limitations in this review may stem from heterogeneity in the acculturation and geography of participants and analysis by a single reviewer. Implications include considering the range of information sources and the influence they have on risk perception and risk mitigation for this population.
CONCLUSION & SIGNIFICANCE: Adolescents describe many modifiable influences on contraception access and use. Misperceptions related to contraception, stemming from beliefs and perceptions, can be corrected through increased access to reliable sources of sex education, parental support, and direct access to nurses and healthcare providers. Awareness of these influences can inform further research and intervention development to address these health disparities.
西班牙裔美国青少年怀孕率很高,后果严重。与白人青少年相比,西班牙裔青少年较少使用避孕措施,且常常选择效果较差的避孕方式。能否获得避孕措施是使用避孕措施的主要障碍,这导致西班牙裔青少年的怀孕率相对较高且存在差异。本整合性综述确定了居住在美国的13至17岁西班牙裔女性在获得和使用避孕措施方面的促进因素和障碍。
遵循惠特莫尔和克纳夫(2005年)的方法以及PRISMA指南,从PUBMED、CINAHL和EMBASE中检索同行评审研究。使用混合方法评估工具评估研究质量,并使用主题分析对障碍和促进因素进行分类。
在检索到的131项研究中,16项符合纳入标准。个人、人际和医疗保健提供者因素被确定为障碍和促进因素的主要类别,结构问题构成另一个障碍类别。个人层面的障碍占比过高,并进一步细分为以下主题:信念/误解、不喜欢避孕、怀孕风险认知、知识缺乏和缺乏控制权。在个人、人际和结构层面都发现了与文化和宗教影响相关的障碍。最常报告的促进因素是认为父母在讨论性健康时感到自在以及过去有过怀孕经历。
本综述的局限性可能源于参与者在文化适应和地理位置上的异质性以及由单一评审员进行分析。其启示包括考虑信息来源的范围及其对该人群风险认知和风险缓解的影响。
青少年描述了许多对获得和使用避孕措施有可改变的影响。源于信念和认知的与避孕相关的误解可以通过增加获得可靠的性教育来源、父母支持以及直接接触护士和医疗保健提供者来纠正。了解这些影响可为进一步的研究和干预发展提供信息,以解决这些健康差异问题。