Buck Deborah, Mulligan Lee D, Lennox Charlotte, Bowden Jana, Minchin Matilda, Kemp Lowenna, Devine Lucy, Southworth Joshua, Ghafur Falaq, Robinson Catherine, Shepherd Andrew, Shaw Jennifer J, Forsyth Katrina
Social Care and Society, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Division of Psychology and Mental Health, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Med Sci Law. 2025 Jul;65(3):194-206. doi: 10.1177/00258024241264762. Epub 2024 Jul 25.
Many people are living in prison with a range of social care needs, for example, requiring support with washing, eating, getting around safely, and/or maintaining relationships. However, social care for this vulnerable group is generally inadequate. There is uncertainty and confusion about who is legally responsible for this and how it can best be provided, and a lack of integration with healthcare. We used realist-informed approaches to develop an initial programme theory (IPT) for identifying/assessing social care needs of, and providing care to, male adults in prison and on release. IPT development was an iterative process involving (a) an initial scoping of the international prison literature; (b) scoping prison and community social care policy documents and guidelines; (c) full systematic search of the international prison social care literature; (d) insights from the community social care literature; (e) stakeholder workshops. Information from 189 documents/sources and stakeholder feedback informed the IPT, which recommended that models of prison social care should be: trauma-informed; well integrated with health, criminal justice, third-sector services and families; and person-centred involving service-users in all aspects including co-production of care plans, goals, and staff training/awareness programmes. Our IPT provides an initial gold standard model for social care provision for people in prison and on release. The model, named Empowered Together, will be evaluated in a future trial and will be of interest to those working in the criminal justice system, care providers and commissioners, local authorities, housing authorities, voluntary groups, and service-users and their families.
许多人在监狱中生活,有着一系列社会照料需求,例如,在洗漱、饮食、安全出行和/或维持人际关系方面需要帮助。然而,对这一弱势群体的社会照料总体上是不足的。对于谁在法律上对此负责以及如何能最好地提供照料存在不确定性和困惑,并且缺乏与医疗保健的整合。我们采用基于现实主义的方法来制定一个初始项目理论(IPT),以识别/评估监狱中和出狱后的成年男性的社会照料需求并为其提供照料。IPT的制定是一个迭代过程,包括:(a)对国际监狱文献进行初步范围界定;(b)梳理监狱和社区社会照料政策文件及指南;(c)全面系统地检索国际监狱社会照料文献;(d)从社区社会照料文献中获取见解;(e)举办利益相关者研讨会。来自189份文件/来源的信息以及利益相关者的反馈为IPT提供了依据,该理论建议监狱社会照料模式应:具备创伤知情理念;与健康、刑事司法、第三部门服务及家庭充分整合;以个人为中心,让服务使用者参与包括共同制定护理计划、目标以及工作人员培训/意识提升项目等各个方面。我们的IPT为监狱中和出狱后的人员提供社会照料提供了一个初始的黄金标准模式。这个名为“共同赋能”的模式将在未来的试验中进行评估,并且会引起刑事司法系统工作人员、护理提供者和专员、地方当局、住房当局、志愿团体以及服务使用者及其家庭的兴趣