Nguyen Phi-Hung, Thi Nguyen Lan-Anh, Le Hong-Quan, Tran Linh-Chi
Research Center of Applied Sciences, Faculty of Business, FPT University, Hanoi, 100000, Vietnam.
Heliyon. 2024 Jun 29;10(13):e33493. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e33493. eCollection 2024 Jul 15.
As potent financial instruments channeling capital into climate and environmental projects, green bonds' issuance is frustrated by myriad obstacles. Therefore, this study aims to explore the critical barriers to green bond issuance in Vietnam. This study elucidates the salient barriers by utilizing an integrated multi-criteria decision-making methodology synthesizing the Fuzzy set theory-based Delphi, Decision-Making Trial and Evaluation Laboratory (DEMATEL), and DEMATEL-based Analytic Network Process (DANP). An extensive literature review of green bonds delineates five key dimensions related to impediments: Policy, Market, Financial, Capacity, and Awareness, with 38 discrete indicators representing potential obstacles. Firstly, employing a Fuzzy Delphi survey of 16 experts, 32 indicators are distilled for further analysis. Then, Fuzzy DEMATEL modeling evaluates the interrelationships and interactions among barriers. Finally, DANP is applied to obtain the relative importance of key barriers. Results unveil the five most formidable barriers as a weak regulatory framework and infrastructure (PO1), Limited availability of green bond issuance guidelines and templates (PO2), Insufficient incentives or tax benefits for green bond issuers (PO3), Limited coordination and alignment with international green bond standards (PO5), Lack of investor confidence in the quality and credibility of green projects (AW4), and Capacity constraints among issuers, particularly in smaller organisations or government agencies (CA1). The research contributes to the broader literature on green finance and offers valuable insights for promoting sustainable finance practices in Vietnam and other developing economies.
作为将资本引入气候和环境项目的有力金融工具,绿色债券的发行受到了众多障碍的阻碍。因此,本研究旨在探讨越南绿色债券发行的关键障碍。本研究通过运用一种综合多标准决策方法来阐明显著障碍,该方法综合了基于模糊集理论的德尔菲法、决策试验与评价实验室法(DEMATEL)以及基于DEMATEL的网络分析法(DANP)。对绿色债券进行的广泛文献综述确定了与障碍相关的五个关键维度:政策、市场、金融、能力和意识,其中38个离散指标代表了潜在障碍。首先,通过对16位专家进行模糊德尔菲调查,提炼出32个指标以供进一步分析。然后,模糊DEMATEL建模评估障碍之间的相互关系和相互作用。最后,应用DANP来确定关键障碍的相对重要性。结果揭示了五个最主要的障碍,即监管框架和基础设施薄弱(PO1)、绿色债券发行指南和模板的可用性有限(PO2)、绿色债券发行人的激励措施或税收优惠不足(PO3)、与国际绿色债券标准的协调和一致性有限(PO5)、投资者对绿色项目质量和可信度缺乏信心(AW4)以及发行人的能力限制,特别是在较小的组织或政府机构中(CA1)。该研究为绿色金融的更广泛文献做出了贡献,并为促进越南和其他发展中经济体可持续金融实践提供了宝贵见解。