Region V Public Health Training Center, University of Michigan-School of Public Health, Ann Arbor, Michigan (Mss Zemmel and Kulik and Drs Karnik, Power, and Leider); Department of Epidemiology, University of Michigan-School of Public Health, Ann Arbor, Michigan (Mss Zemmel and Kulik and Dr Power); and Division of Health Policy and Management, University of Minnesota School of Public Health, Minneapolis, Minnesota (Drs Karnik and Leider).
J Public Health Manag Pract. 2024;30(6):E297-E305. doi: 10.1097/PHH.0000000000002006. Epub 2024 Jul 22.
Recent shifts in public health (PH) include consistent budget cuts, workforce attrition, and loss of vital skills and institutional knowledge followed by heightened pandemic-driven attention, new responsibilities, and renewed funding. This study investigates whether frontline employees working in different types of public health departments have different educational characteristics and whether these characteristics are associated with differentials in skill gaps toward informing targeted interventions to nurture a competitive workforce.
Utilizing 2021 Public Health Workforce Interests and Needs Survey (PH WINS) data, we document variations in educational qualifications, skill gaps, and workforce characteristics among frontline workers in different sizes of health departments and examine attributes associated with skill gaps: level and field of education, years of experience, program areas, and job classifications using a negative binomial model.
Skill gaps in resource management, systems and strategic thinking, and change management persist across all local health departments (LHDs), but the extent of these gaps is greater in small LHDs. Small LHDs also have few employees with graduate and public health degrees. Additionally, whereas public health degrees were not associated with fewer skill gaps, tenure in public health was, suggesting people learn on the job.
The results highlight the role regional training centers can play in emphasizing the need for strategic skills and foundational public health concepts, as well as customizing training content by agency size and educational levels to improve accessibility, particularly for small LHDs with resource constraints.
公共卫生领域最近发生了转变,包括预算持续削减、劳动力流失,以及关键技能和机构知识的丧失,随后又出现了大流行驱动的高度关注、新的责任和重新获得的资金。本研究旨在调查在不同类型的公共卫生部门工作的一线员工是否具有不同的教育特征,以及这些特征是否与技能差距的差异相关,以针对特定干预措施,培养有竞争力的劳动力。
利用 2021 年公共卫生劳动力兴趣和需求调查(PH WINS)数据,我们记录了不同规模卫生部门的一线工作人员在教育资格、技能差距和劳动力特征方面的差异,并使用负二项模型检查与技能差距相关的属性:教育水平和领域、工作经验年限、项目领域和工作分类。
资源管理、系统和战略思维以及变革管理方面的技能差距在所有地方卫生部门(LHD)中都存在,但在小 LHD 中这些差距更为严重。小 LHD 中也只有少数员工拥有研究生和公共卫生学位。此外,虽然公共卫生学位与较少的技能差距无关,但在公共卫生领域的工作年限与技能差距有关,这表明人们是在工作中学习的。
研究结果强调了区域培训中心可以发挥的作用,即强调战略技能和基础公共卫生概念的必要性,并根据机构规模和教育水平定制培训内容,以提高可及性,特别是对于资源有限的小 LHD。