Nap Henk Herman, Stolwijk Nathalie E, Ipakchian Askari Sima, Lukkien Dirk R M, Hofstede Bob M, Morresi Nicole, Casaccia Sara, Amabili Giulio, Bevilacqua Roberta, Margaritini Arianna, Barbarossa Federico, Lin Chien-Ju, Chieh Hsiao-Feng, Su Fong-Chin, Revel Gian Marco, Tesfay Ephrem, Bai Dorothy, Wirtjes Claire, Hsu Yeh-Liang
Vilans Centre of Expertise for Long-Term Care, Digital Care, Utrecht, Netherlands.
Copernicus Institute of Sustainable Development, Utrecht University, Utrecht, Netherlands.
Front Dement. 2024 Jul 18;3:1400624. doi: 10.3389/frdem.2024.1400624. eCollection 2024.
With a decreasing workforce of carers and a transition from care homes to home care, people with dementia (PwD) increasingly rely on informal caregivers (ICs) and assistive technologies (ATs). There is growing evidence that ATs in the home environment can reduce workload for formal carers (FCs) and ICs, reduce care costs, and can have a positive influence on quality of life (QoL) for PwD and their caregivers. In practice, using multiple ATs still often implies using different separate point solutions and applications. However, the integral, combined use of the data generated using various applications can potentially enhance the insight into the health and wellbeing status of PwD and can provide decision support for carers. The purpose of the current study was to evaluate the use of a DSS that integrated multiple ATs into one dashboard through a small-scale field study.
The current study presents the formative evaluation of a Decision Support System (DSS) connected to multiple ATs. This DSS has been developed by means of co-creation during an international project. The DSS provides an insight into the physical and cognitive status of a PwD, as well as an insight into sleep activity and general wellbeing. Semi-structured interview sessions were held in three countries (Netherlands, Italy, and Taiwan) with 41 participants to gain insight into the experiences of formal and informal carers and PwD with both the ATs and the DSS Alpha prototype dashboard.
The results showed that participants using the DSS were satisfied and perceived added value and a fit with certain care demands from the PwD. In general, ICs and FCs have limited insight into the status of PwD living independently at home, and in these moments, the DSS dashboard and AT bundle can provide valuable insights. Participants experienced the DSS dashboard as well-organized and easy to navigate. The accuracy of the data displayed in the dashboard is important, the context, and (perceived) privacy issues should be tackled according to all users. Furthermore, based in the insight gained during the evaluation a set of design improvements was composed which can be used to further improve the DSS for the Beta evaluation.
The current paper evaluates a possible solution for excess AT usage and how the use of a DSS which integrated multiple AT into one single technology could support caregivers in providing care for PwD. The formative evaluation scrutinized the integration of the developed DSS and the composed bundle of ATs across diverse cultural contexts. Insights from multi-center observations shed light on user experiences, encompassing overall usability, navigational efficacy, and attitudes toward the system. FCs and ICs expressed positivity toward the DSS dashboard's design and functionalities, highlighting its utility in remote monitoring, tracking changes in the person's abilities, and managing urgent situations. There is a need for personalized solutions and the findings contribute to a nuanced understanding of DSS and AT integration, providing insights for future developments and research in the field of DSS for the care of PwD.
随着护理人员数量的减少以及护理模式从养老院向家庭护理的转变,痴呆症患者越来越依赖非正式护理人员和辅助技术。越来越多的证据表明,家庭环境中的辅助技术可以减轻正式护理人员和非正式护理人员的工作量,降低护理成本,并对痴呆症患者及其护理人员的生活质量产生积极影响。在实践中,使用多种辅助技术通常仍意味着使用不同的独立单点解决方案和应用程序。然而,综合利用各种应用程序生成的数据有可能增强对痴呆症患者健康和幸福状况的了解,并为护理人员提供决策支持。本研究的目的是通过一项小规模实地研究,评估将多种辅助技术集成到一个仪表板中的决策支持系统的使用情况。
本研究对连接多种辅助技术的决策支持系统进行了形成性评估。该决策支持系统是在一个国际项目中通过共同创造开发的。该决策支持系统可以洞察痴呆症患者的身体和认知状况,以及睡眠活动和总体幸福感。在三个国家(荷兰、意大利和台湾)对41名参与者进行了半结构化访谈,以了解正式和非正式护理人员以及痴呆症患者对辅助技术和决策支持系统阿尔法原型仪表板的体验。
结果表明,使用该决策支持系统的参与者感到满意,并认为其具有附加价值,且符合痴呆症患者的某些护理需求。总体而言,非正式护理人员和正式护理人员对独立居住在家中的痴呆症患者的状况了解有限,在这些情况下,决策支持系统仪表板和辅助技术组合可以提供有价值的见解。参与者认为决策支持系统仪表板组织良好,易于操作。仪表板中显示的数据准确性很重要,所有用户都应解决相关背景和(感知到的)隐私问题。此外,根据评估过程中获得的见解,制定了一组设计改进措施,可用于进一步改进决策支持系统以进行贝塔评估。
本文评估了辅助技术使用过多的一种可能解决方案,以及将多种辅助技术集成到单一技术中的决策支持系统如何支持护理人员为痴呆症患者提供护理。形成性评估审查了所开发的决策支持系统与在不同文化背景下组成的辅助技术组合的集成情况。多中心观察的见解揭示了用户体验,包括总体可用性、导航效率以及对系统的态度。正式护理人员和非正式护理人员对决策支持系统仪表板的设计和功能表示肯定,强调了其在远程监测、跟踪患者能力变化以及管理紧急情况方面的效用。需要个性化解决方案,这些发现有助于对决策支持系统和辅助技术集成有更细致入微的理解,为痴呆症患者护理领域决策支持系统的未来发展和研究提供见解。