Vallortigara Giorgio, Vitiello Giuseppe
Centre for Mind/Brain Sciences, University of Trento, Piazza della Manifattura 1, Rovereto, Trento I-38068, Italy.
Department of Physics 'E.R. Caianiello', University of Salerno, Via Giovanni Paolo II, 132, Fisciano (Salerno) I-84084, Italy.
R Soc Open Sci. 2024 Jul 31;11(7):240465. doi: 10.1098/rsos.240465. eCollection 2024 Jul.
The asymmetry between the left and right sides seems to be a general principle of organization of the nervous systems in Bilateria, providing the foundations for a plethora of leftward and rightward biases in behaviour as documented in species ranging from nematodes to humans. Several theories have been put forward to account for the existence and maintenance in the evolution of the asymmetric organization of the brain at both individual and population levels. However, what is missing in theorizing about the evolution of brain asymmetry is an overarching general hypothesis that may subsume all different aspects of current models. Here, we tried to provide an overarching general framework based on the energy and free-energy minimization principle, which proved so valuable in other areas of neuroscience. We found that at the individual level the antisymmetric singlet configuration realizes the lowest energy state of the system, whereas at the group level, the spontaneous emergence of directional asymmetry arises as a consequence of the minimization of the free energy of the system, which guarantees its stability and equilibrium. We thus argue that the various phenomenological aspects of brain asymmetry that have been captured in biology-e.g. sparing of neural tissue, control of unitary motor responses and, at the population level, evolutionarily stable strategies described by mathematical games theory-may be thought of as the manifestation of a more general principle of energy minimization generating, among others, asymmetry of the brains.
左右两侧的不对称似乎是两侧对称动物神经系统组织的一个普遍原则,为从线虫到人类等物种中记录的大量行为中的左右偏向提供了基础。已经提出了几种理论来解释大脑不对称组织在个体和群体水平进化中的存在和维持。然而,在关于大脑不对称进化的理论中,缺少一个可能包含当前模型所有不同方面的总体一般假设。在这里,我们试图提供一个基于能量和自由能最小化原则的总体一般框架,这一原则在神经科学的其他领域已被证明非常有价值。我们发现,在个体水平上,反对称单重态构型实现了系统的最低能量状态,而在群体水平上,方向不对称的自发出现是系统自由能最小化的结果,这保证了系统的稳定性和平衡。因此,我们认为生物学中所捕捉到的大脑不对称的各种现象学方面——例如神经组织的保留、单一运动反应的控制,以及在群体水平上,数学博弈论所描述的进化稳定策略——可能被认为是一种更普遍的能量最小化原则的表现,这种原则除其他外还产生了大脑的不对称。