Medical MBChB Graduate 2023, University of Aberdeen School of Medicine and Dentistry, Polwarth Building, Foresterhill Rd, Aberdeen, AB25 2ZD, UK.
ST3 Clinical Radiology, Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, Foresterhill Health Campus, Foresterhill Rd, Aberdeen, AB25 2ZN, UK.
BMC Med Educ. 2024 Aug 1;24(1):830. doi: 10.1186/s12909-024-05461-8.
Radiological imaging has played an important role in diagnostic medicine for over a century, though it is known to contribute to dermatological conditions, cataracts, and cancer. The associated risk of harm has led to the introduction of protective regulations around the world. Present-day NHS clinicians are increasingly requesting and relying on diagnostic imaging. Knowledge surrounding the radiation doses of common radiological investigations and the associated risks is imperative, and on a global level has been found to be inadequate. Consequently, there is a need for the formal inclusion of teaching within training programmes.
AIMS/OBJECTIVES: This prospective audit aims to establish the knowledge of radiation doses and risks of common radiological investigations of both medical students and referrers within four NHS Health Boards based in the North of Scotland. It also seeks to establish prior teaching and the preference for further educational interventions.
Referrers should have adequate knowledge of radiation doses and the risks associated with common radiological investigations.
The standard should be achieved by 90% of referrers.
A 19-question online survey was devised to include subjective and objective questions on ionising radiation awareness, education preference, and respondent demographics, based on RCR (Royal College of Radiologists) audit criteria and previous studies. Data collection was conducted between the 22/02/23 to the 22/03/2023 and the questionnaire was distributed to senior medical students and radiological referrers of different grades within NHS Grampian, NHS Highland, NHS Shetland, and NHS Orkney. A descriptive analysis of the data was undertaken using Microsoft Excel Version 16.71.
Two hundred eight questionnaires were completed. 22.11% (n = 46) of the sample population had received no prior teaching on the topic of ionising radiation. Over half of the respondents (51.92%, n = 108) rated the importance of radiation risks as either important or extremely important, with 69.71% (n = 145) of participants rating their perceived knowledge as limited or average. Most correctly identified that a CT scan (n = 203), PET-CT scan (n = 199) and a chest x-ray (n = 196) exposed patients to ionising radiation. A small proportion of the participants incorrectly thought that an MRI scan (n = 21) and an ultrasound scan (n = 2) involved ionising radiation. The results obtained failed to meet the RCR audit target, which states that 90% of doctors should be aware of common radiological doses. It was observed that only 17.79% (n = 37) of survey respondents scored over 50% in the knowledge assessment, with the median knowledge score of the whole cohort being 2.5 out of 9 (27.78%). Respondents who had prior teaching on the topic performed better those who had no prior teaching, with average scores of 3.19 (35.44%) and 2.04 (22.67%) respectively. Senior clinicians performed better when compared to junior clinicians and medical students.
CONCLUSION & FUTURE RECOMMENDATIONS: This audit found that the knowledge of radiation risks within the North of Scotland in the selected sample population was insufficient across all levels of the clinical team. Further, continuous education around the topic and future audit opportunities may help to optimise knowledge and training.
放射影像学在诊断医学中已有一个多世纪的重要作用,但已知其会导致皮肤病、白内障和癌症。其相关的危害风险导致了世界各地都出台了保护法规。如今,英国国家医疗服务体系的临床医生越来越多地要求并依赖诊断成像。了解常见放射学检查的辐射剂量及其相关风险是至关重要的,在全球范围内,人们发现这方面的知识还不够充分。因此,有必要在培训计划中正式纳入教学内容。
目的/目标:本前瞻性审计旨在确定基于苏格兰北部四个英国国家医疗服务体系卫生委员会的医学生和转诊医生对常见放射学检查的辐射剂量和风险的了解程度。它还旨在确定之前的教学情况以及对进一步教育干预的偏好。
转诊医生应充分了解常见放射学检查的辐射剂量和相关风险。
转诊医生应达到 90%的标准。
根据 RCR(皇家放射科医师学院)审计标准和先前的研究,设计了一份包含电离辐射意识、教育偏好和受访者人口统计学的 19 个问题的在线调查,包括主观和客观问题。数据收集于 2023 年 2 月 22 日至 3 月 22 日之间进行,问卷分发给 NHS Grampian、NHS Highland、NHS Shetland 和 NHS Orkney 的不同年级的高级医学生和放射学转诊医生。使用 Microsoft Excel 版本 16.71 对数据进行描述性分析。
共完成了 208 份问卷。22.11%(n=46)的样本人群没有接受过关于电离辐射主题的预先教学。超过一半的受访者(51.92%,n=108)认为辐射风险的重要性为重要或极其重要,69.71%(n=145)的参与者认为他们的感知知识有限或平均。大多数人正确地识别出 CT 扫描(n=203)、PET-CT 扫描(n=199)和胸部 X 光(n=196)使患者暴露于电离辐射下。一小部分参与者错误地认为 MRI 扫描(n=21)和超声扫描(n=2)涉及电离辐射。所获得的结果未达到 RCR 审计目标,该目标规定 90%的医生应了解常见的放射剂量。观察到只有 17.79%(n=37)的调查受访者在知识评估中得分超过 50%,整个队列的中位数知识得分为 9 分中的 2.5 分(27.78%)。接受过该主题教学的受访者比没有接受过教学的受访者表现更好,平均得分为 3.19(35.44%)和 2.04(22.67%)。与初级临床医生相比,高级临床医生表现更好。
本审计发现,在所选择的样本人群中,苏格兰北部的辐射风险知识在临床团队的各个层面都不足。此外,围绕该主题的持续教育和未来的审计机会可能有助于优化知识和培训。