Espanola Animal Hospital, Greater Sudbury, 3557 Errington Avenue, Chelmsford, Ontario P0M 1L0 (Rocheleau, Robson); Nexus Veterinary Bone & Joint Center, 3700 O'Donnell Street, Baltimore, Maryland 21224, USA (Dycus); Skylos Sports Medicine, 434 Prospect Boulevard, Frederick, Maryland 21701, USA (Lotsikas).
Can Vet J. 2024 Aug;65(8):781-790.
The aim of this study was to document perceived frequency of medial shoulder syndrome and instability (MSS/MSI) among dogs, and preferred diagnostic and treatment options related to the condition, among American or European Colleges of Veterinary Surgeons (ACVS/ECVS) diplomates, American College of Veterinary Sports Medicine and Rehabilitation (ACVSMR) diplomates, and dual diplomates of ACVS/ECVS and ACVSMR (double-Boarded diplomates).
An invitation to complete an online survey was sent to diplomates email listservs.
The known response rate for the survey was 15.8% (160 of 1014 email addresses). There was a difference ( = 0.006) among groups in number of cases of MSS/MSI seen, with ACVS/ECVS diplomates and double-Boarded diplomates seeing 0 to 5 cases per year (80.7 and 72.7%, respectively) and ACVSMR diplomates (32% of total respondents) seeing 11 to 26+ cases annually. The majority of all respondents (56.4%) felt the likely cause of MSS/MSI to be chronic/repetitive strain. Diagnostically, most respondents (78%) relied on shoulder abduction angles; however, most felt it was a questionable or somewhat accurate diagnostic test. The ACVSMR diplomates (88%) relied on musculoskeletal ultrasound as their preferred diagnostic modality, compared to only 35% of ACVS/ECVS diplomates and 45% of double-Boarded diplomates. Preferred treatment was rehabilitation with surgery for unresponsive cases, as reported by 86.9% of all respondents. Preferred surgical treatment was prosthetic ligament reconstruction (62.7%).
Despite the low known response rate of this survey, there were significant differences among specialties regarding frequency of MSS/MSI cases seen per year and preferred diagnostic modalities. However, there were no differences among specialties regarding the suspected underlying causes of MSS/MSI and initial treatment strategies.
本研究旨在记录美国或欧洲兽医外科学院(ACVS/ECVS)院士、美国兽医运动医学与康复学院(ACVSMR)院士以及 ACVS/ECVS 和 ACVSMR 的双重院士(双板院士)对狗的肩袖综合征和不稳定(MSS/MSI)的感知频率,以及与该疾病相关的首选诊断和治疗方案。
向院士的电子邮件列表发送了参加在线调查的邀请。
调查的已知回复率为 15.8%(1014 个电子邮件地址中的 160 个)。在看到 MSS/MSI 病例数方面,各小组之间存在差异(=0.006),ACVS/ECVS 院士和双板院士每年看到 0 到 5 例(分别为 80.7%和 72.7%),而 ACVSMR 院士(占总受访者的 32%)每年看到 11 到 26+例。大多数受访者(56.4%)认为 MSS/MSI 的可能原因是慢性/反复劳损。在诊断方面,大多数受访者(78%)依赖于肩部外展角度;然而,大多数人认为这是一种可疑或有点准确的诊断测试。ACVSMR 院士(88%)依赖于肌肉骨骼超声作为他们首选的诊断方式,而只有 35%的 ACVS/ECVS 院士和 45%的双板院士这样做。作为回应,86.9%的受访者报告说,首选的治疗方法是对无反应的病例进行康复治疗,然后进行手术。所有受访者中首选的手术治疗方法是假体韧带重建(62.7%)。
尽管这项调查的已知回复率较低,但在每年看到 MSS/MSI 病例的频率和首选诊断方式方面,各专业之间存在显著差异。然而,在 MSS/MSI 的潜在原因和初始治疗策略方面,各专业之间没有差异。