Lyon Christopher
Department of Environment and Geography, University of York, York, YO10 5DD, UK.
Leverhulme Centre for Anthropocene Biodiversity, University of York, York, YO10 5DD, UK.
HEC Forum. 2025 Mar;37(1):65-105. doi: 10.1007/s10730-024-09528-3. Epub 2024 Aug 2.
The Canadian approach to assisted dying, Medical Assistance in Dying (MAiD), as of early 2024, is assessed for its ability to protect patients from criminal healthcare serial killing (HSK) to evaluate the strength of its safeguards. MAiD occurs through euthanasia or self-administered assisted suicide (EAS) and is legal or considered in many countries and jurisdictions. Clinicians involved in HSK typically target patients with the same clinical features as MAiD-eligible patients. They may draw on similar rationales, e.g., to end perceived patient suffering and provide pleasure for the clinician. HSK can remain undetected or unconfirmed for considerable periods owing to a lack of staff background checks, poor surveillance and oversight, and a failure by authorities to act on concerns from colleagues, patients, or witnesses. The Canadian MAiD system, effectively euthanasia-based, has similar features with added opportunities for killing afforded by clinicians' exemption from criminal culpability for homicide and assisted suicide offences amid broad patient eligibility criteria. An assessment of the Canadian model offers insights for enhancing safeguards and detecting abuses in there and other jurisdictions with or considering legal EAS. Short of an unlikely recriminalization of EAS, better clinical safeguarding measures, standards, vetting and training of those involved in MAiD, and a radical restructuring of its oversight and delivery can help mitigate the possibility of abuses in a system mandated to accommodate homicidal clinicians.
截至2024年初,对加拿大的协助死亡方式,即医疗协助死亡(MAiD),进行评估,以考察其保护患者免受医疗连环杀人(HSK)的能力,从而评估其保障措施的力度。MAiD通过安乐死或自我实施的协助自杀(EAS)进行,在许多国家和司法管辖区是合法的或正在被考虑。参与HSK的临床医生通常将具有与符合MAiD条件的患者相同临床特征的患者作为目标。他们可能会采用类似的理由,例如结束患者的感知痛苦并为临床医生提供愉悦感。由于缺乏工作人员背景调查、监督和监管不力,以及当局未能对同事、患者或证人的担忧采取行动,HSK可能在相当长的一段时间内未被发现或未得到证实。加拿大的MAiD系统实际上是以安乐死为基础的,具有类似的特征,而且在广泛的患者资格标准下,临床医生可免于对杀人及协助自杀罪行承担刑事责任,这增加了杀人的机会。对加拿大模式的评估为加强保障措施以及在该国及其他有或正在考虑合法EAS的司法管辖区发现滥用行为提供了见解。除了不太可能重新将EAS定为犯罪外,更好的临床保障措施、标准、对参与MAiD人员的审查和培训,以及对其监督和实施进行彻底重组,有助于降低一个旨在容纳杀人临床医生的系统中出现滥用行为的可能性。